And I'll Scratch Yours

Summary

And I'll Scratch Yours
And I'll Scratch Yours.jpg
Studio album by
Various Artists
Released24 September 2013
Recorded2009–2013
GenreArt rock
Length54:43
LabelReal World Records
ProducerPeter Gabriel
Peter Gabriel chronology
Live Blood
(2012)
And I'll Scratch Yours
(2013)
Back to Front: Live in London
(2014)
Professional ratings
Aggregate scores
SourceRating
Metacritic63/100[1]
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusic3/5 stars[2]
Pitchfork4.9/10[3]

And I'll Scratch Yours (originally announced as I'll Scratch Yours) is a compilation album developed by the English rock musician Peter Gabriel. Initially slated for release in 2010, the album was released on 24 September 2013. The original concept was that And I'll Scratch Yours would serve as a companion piece to Gabriel's 2010 covers album Scratch My Back. The idea was to give the artists whose songs Gabriel covered on Scratch My Back a medium to reciprocate – And I'll Scratch Yours would feature those artists covering Gabriel's songs. However, three artists (David Bowie, Neil Young, and Radiohead) declined to record covers of Gabriel's material. Therefore, three new artists (Brian Eno, Joseph Arthur, and Feist) contributed covers to the album instead.

Album history

And I'll Scratch Yours was originally announced and scheduled for release in 2010, but several artists failed to deliver material as promised, or declined to participate in the project altogether. The album was subsequently postponed, though six tracks from it were released on iTunes between January and June 2010, and two of those tracks have also appeared on vinyl, as B-sides. In October 2011, Gabriel stated that he had "given up" waiting for the remaining artists to contribute to the project, and was looking to have other artists record cover material so that he could release And I'll Scratch Yours sometime "next year" (i.e., 2012). Eventually, Feist and Joseph Arthur were recruited to cover for some of the missing artists, and the album was announced for release on 23 September 2013.

Tracks released in 2010

Twelve artists were covered by Gabriel on the Scratch My Back album; 13 if one includes the cover of The Kinks' "Waterloo Sunset" (written by Ray Davies) on the limited edition bonus disc. However, only six artists originally submitted reciprocal covers of Gabriel material in connection with I'll Scratch Yours. Gabriel originally intended to release Scratch My Back and I'll Scratch Yours simultaneously,[4] but as completion of the latter dragged out, it was instead decided to release a series of double A-sided singles with one song from each album every new full moon during 2010 on iTunes.[5] In order of release, the I'll Scratch Yours tracks were:

On 17 April 2010 "The Book of Love" (by Gabriel) backed with "Not One of Us" (by Merritt) as well as "Flume" (by Gabriel) backed with "Come Talk to Me" (by Bon Iver) were released on 7" vinyl to independent record stores.[6]

Later developments

Of the seven remaining artists covered on Scratch My Back, Radiohead, David Bowie, Neil Young, and Ray Davies declined to participate in the I'll Scratch Yours project. It was reported[7] on a January 2010 Peter Gabriel podcast that Radiohead would cover "Wallflower" from Gabriel's fourth self-titled album. However, Gabriel subsequently reported in an interview in The Guardian that Radiohead had withdrawn from the project after hearing his version of their song "Street Spirit (Fade Out)".[8]

Regina Spektor, Randy Newman and Arcade Fire did ultimately submit material to the project, albeit later than expected. Brian Eno who co-wrote "Heroes" with David Bowie, covered "Mother of Violence". In an October 2011 interview published in Rolling Stone, Gabriel said, "I've sort of given up waiting for the others ... So now I think that I might try to find three or four other people to cover my stuff so that I can make an album out of that, and then get that out next year in some form.".[9]

Track listing

All songs written by Peter Gabriel except "Mother of Violence," written by Peter Gabriel and Jill Gabriel.

No.TitlePerformerLength
1."I Don't Remember"David Byrne3:38
2."Come Talk to Me"Bon Iver6:20
3."Blood of Eden"Regina Spektor4:39
4."Not One of Us"Stephin Merritt3:49
5."Shock the Monkey"Joseph Arthur5:49
6."Big Time"Randy Newman3:29
7."Games Without Frontiers"Arcade Fire3:22
8."Mercy Street"Elbow5:28
9."Mother of Violence"Brian Eno3:00
10."Don't Give Up"Feist feat. Timber Timbre5:28
11."Solsbury Hill"Lou Reed5:24
12."Biko"Paul Simon4:19
Total length:54:50

Personnel

  • Tony Cousins – mastering
  • Marc Bessant – design, cover
  • Steve Gschmeissner – cover, back cover
  • David Hiscock – Peter Gabriel bloodspot
  • Anna Gabriel – artists photography (except Lou Reed, Stephin Merritt, Arcade Fire, Feist and Regina Spektor)
  • Lou Reed – photography (Lou Reed)
  • Alex Hammond – photography (Stephin Merritt)
  • Korey Richey – photography (Arcade Fire)
  • Ben Feist – photography (Feist)
  • Jack Dishel – photography (Regina Spektor)
  • Nige Tassell – sleeve notes

I Don't Remember

  • David Byrne – vocals, instruments
  • Patrick Dillett – mixing

Come Talk to Me

Blood of Eden

  • Joe Mendelson – production, arrangement, instruments, mixing
  • Jack Dishel – production, arrangement, instruments, vocals
  • Regina Spektor – production, arrangement, instruments, vocals

Not One of Us

  • Stephin Merritt – production, recording, mixing
  • Charles Newman – production, recording, mixing

Shock the Monkey

Big Time

  • Bruno Coon – production, mixing

Games Without Frontiers

  • Arcade Fire – production
  • Mark Lawson – recording
  • Korey Richey – recording
  • Tom Elmhirst – mixing

Mercy Street

  • Elbow – production
  • Craig Potter – mixing

Don't Give Up

  • Mockyorgan, synthesizer, production
  • Leslie Feist – vocals, guitar, synthesizer, pedals, production
  • Taylor Kirk – vocals, guitar
  • Paul Taylor – percussion
  • Mika Posen – violin
  • Morri$ – production
  • Renaud Letang – mixing
  • Robbie Lackritz – recording, engineering

Solsbury Hill

  • Lou Reed – production, mixing
  • Eric Kramer – engineering
  • Mike Rathke – additional guitar
  • Sarth Calhoun – additional programming

Biko

References

  1. ^ "Peter Gabriel Tribute Album: And I'll Scratch Yours". Metacritic. Retrieved 5 November 2013.
  2. ^ Erlewine, Stephen Thomas. And I'll Scratch Yours at AllMusic. Retrieved 6 October 2013.
  3. ^ Deusner, Stephen M. "Peter Gabriel | And I'll Scratch Yours". Pitchfork Media. Retrieved 6 October 2013.
  4. ^ Jon Pareles (1 March 2010). "Peter Gabriel Says, 'I'll Sing Yours, You Sing Mine'". The New York Times. Retrieved 5 March 2010.
  5. ^ McCormick, Neil (11 February 2010). "Peter Gabriel: Scratch My Back, CD review". The Daily Telegraph. London. Archived from the original on 15 February 2010. Retrieved 19 February 2010.
  6. ^ "2 'Scratch' 7-inch singles for Record Store Day". Petergabriel.com. 10 March 2010. Archived from the original on 30 December 2010. Retrieved 13 March 2010.
  7. ^ News Archive | Radiohead to cover Peter Gabriel's 'Wallflower' Archived 30 January 2010 at the Wayback Machine ateaseweb.com
  8. ^ Rogers, Jude (2 June 2010). "Peter Gabriel: 'It doesn't have anything to do with witchcraft!'". The Guardian. London.
  9. ^ Peter Gabriel: Story That Bruce Springsteen Was Inspiration for 'Solsbury Hill' Is 'Hogwash' | Music News | Rolling Stone