|Consorts||Anat, Athtart, Arsay, Tallay, Pidray|
|Deities of the ancient Near East|
|Religions of the ancient Near East|
Baal (/ˈbeɪəl, ˈbɑːəl/),[a] properly Baʿal,[b] was a title and honorific meaning "owner", "lord" in the Northwest Semitic languages spoken in the Levant during antiquity. From its use among people, it came to be applied to gods. Scholars previously associated the theonym with solar cults and with a variety of unrelated patron deities, but inscriptions have shown that the name Baʿal was particularly associated with the storm and fertility god Hadad and his local manifestations.
The Hebrew Bible includes use of the term in reference to various Levantine deities, often with application towards Hadad, who was decried as a false god. That use was taken over into Christianity and Islam, sometimes under the opprobrious form Beelzebub in demonology.
The spelling of the English term "Baal" derives from the Greek Báal (Βάαλ), which appears in the New Testament and Septuagint, and from its Latinized form Baal, which appears in the Vulgate. These forms in turn derive from the vowel-less Northwest Semitic form BʿL (Phoenician & Punic: 𐤁𐤏𐤋). The word's biblical senses as a Phoenician deity and false gods generally were extended during the Protestant Reformation to denote any idols, icons of the saints, or the Catholic Church generally. In such contexts, it follows the anglicized pronunciation and usually omits any mark between its two As. In close transliteration of the Semitic name, the ayin is represented, as Baʿal.
In the Northwest Semitic languages—Ugaritic, Phoenician, Hebrew, Amorite, and Aramaic—the word baʿal signified "owner" and, by extension, "lord", a "master", or "husband". Cognates include the Akkadian Bēlu (𒂗),[c] Amharic bal (ባል), and Arabic baʿl (بَعْل). Báʿal (בַּעַל) and baʿl still serve as the words for "husband" in modern Hebrew and Arabic respectively. They also appear in some contexts concerning the ownership of things or possession of traits.
Like EN in Sumerian, the Akkadian bēlu and Northwest Semitic baʿal (as well as its feminine form baʿalah) was used as a title of various deities in the Mesopotamian and Semitic pantheons. Only a definitive article, genitive or epithet, or context could establish which particular god was meant.
Baʿal was also used as a proper name by the third millennium BCE, when he appears in a list of deities at Abu Salabikh. Most modern scholarship asserts that this Baʿal—usually distinguished as "The Lord" (הבעל, Ha Baʿal)—was identical with the storm and fertility god Hadad; it also appears in the form Baʿal Haddu. Scholars propose that, as the cult of Hadad increased in importance, his true name came to be seen as too holy for any but the high priest to speak aloud and the alias "Lord" ("Baʿal") was used instead, as "Bel" was used for Marduk among the Babylonians and "Adonai" for Yahweh among the Israelites. A minority propose that Baʿal was a native Canaanite deity whose cult was identified with or absorbed aspects of Adad's. Regardless of their original relationship, by the 1st millennium BCE, the two were distinct: Hadad was worshipped by the Aramaeans and Baʿal by the Phoenicians and other Canaanites.
Baʿal is well-attested in surviving inscriptions and was popular in theophoric names throughout the Levant but he is usually mentioned along with other gods, "his own field of action being seldom defined". Nonetheless, Ugaritic records show him as a weather god, with particular power over lightning, wind, rain, and fertility.[d] The dry summers of the area were explained as Baʿal's time in the underworld and his return in autumn was said to cause the storms which revived the land. Thus, the worship of Baʿal in Canaan—where he eventually supplanted El as the leader of the gods and patron of kingship—was connected to the regions' dependence on rainfall for its agriculture, unlike Egypt and Mesopotamia, which focused on irrigation from their major rivers. Anxiety about the availability of water for crops and trees increased the importance of his cult, which focused attention on his role as a rain god. He was also called upon during battle, showing that he was thought to intervene actively in the world of man, unlike the more aloof El. The Lebanese city of Baalbeck was named after Baal.
The Baʿal of Ugarit was the epithet of Hadad but as the time passed, the epithet became the god's name while Hadad became the epithet. Baʿal was usually said to be the son of Dagan, but appears as one of the sons of El in Ugaritic sources.[e] Both Baʿal and El were associated with the bull in Ugaritic texts, as it symbolized both strength and fertility. The virgin goddess ʿAnat is his older sister and wife. She is sometimes mentioned bearing his child. He held special enmity against snakes, both on their own and as representatives of Yammu (lit. "Sea"), the Canaanite sea god and river god. He fought the Tannin (Tunnanu), the "Twisted Serpent" (Bṭn ʿqltn), "Litan the Fugitive Serpent" (Ltn Bṭn Brḥ, the biblical Leviathan), and the "Mighty One with Seven Heads" (Šlyṭ D.šbʿt Rašm).[f] Baʿal's conflict with Yammu is now generally regarded as the prototype of the vision recorded in the 7th chapter of the biblical Book of Daniel. As vanquisher of the sea, Baʿal was regarded by the Canaanites and Phoenicians as the patron of sailors and sea-going merchants. As vanquisher of Mot, the Canaanite death god, he was known as Baʿal Rāpiʾuma (Bʿl Rpu) and regarded as the leader of the Rephaim (Rpum), the ancestral spirits, particularly those of ruling dynasties.
From Canaan, worship of Baʿal spread to Egypt by the Middle Kingdom and throughout the Mediterranean following the waves of Phoenician colonization in the early 1st millennium BCE. He was described with diverse epithets and, before Ugarit was rediscovered, it was supposed that these referred to distinct local gods. However, as explained by Day, the texts at Ugarit revealed that they were considered "local manifestations of this particular deity, analogous to the local manifestations of the Virgin Mary in the Roman Catholic Church". In those inscriptions, he is frequently described as "Victorious Baʿal" (Aliyn or ẢlỈyn Baʿal), "Mightiest one" (Aliy or ʿAly)[g] or "Mightiest of the Heroes" (Aliy Qrdm), "The Powerful One" (Dmrn), and in his role as patron of the city "Baʿal of Ugarit" (Baʿal Ugarit). As Baʿal Zaphon (Baʿal Ṣapunu), he was particularly associated with his palace atop Jebel Aqra (the ancient Mount Ṣapānu and classical Mons Casius). He is also mentioned as "Winged Baʿal" (Bʿl Knp) and "Baʿal of the Arrows" (Bʿl Ḥẓ). Phoenician and Aramaic inscriptions describe Bʿl Krntryš, "Baʿal of the Lebanon" (Bʿl Lbnn), "Baʿal of Sidon" (Bʿl Ṣdn), Bʿl Ṣmd, "Baʿal of the Heavens" (Baʿal Shamem or Shamayin), Baʿal ʾAddir (Bʿl ʾdr), Baʿal Hammon (Baʿal Ḥamon), Bʿl Mgnm.
Baʿal Hammon was worshipped in the Tyrian colony of Carthage as their supreme god. It is believed that this position developed in the 5th century BCE following the severing of its ties to Tyre following the 480 BCE Battle of Himera. Like Hadad, Baʿal Hammon was a fertility god. Inscriptions about Punic deities tend to be rather uninformative, though, and he has been variously identified as a moon god and as Dagan, the grain god. Rather than the bull, Baʿal Hammon was associated with the ram and depicted with his horns. The archaeological record seems to bear out accusations in Roman sources that the Carthaginians burned their children as human sacrifices to him. He was worshipped as Baʿal Karnaim ("Lord of the Two Horns"), particularly at an open-air sanctuary at Jebel Bu Kornein ("Two-Horn Hill") across the bay from Carthage. His consort was the goddess Tanit.
The epithet Hammon is obscure. Most often, it is connected with the NW Semitic ḥammān ("brazier") and associated with a role as a sun god. Renan and Gibson linked it to Hammon (modern Umm el-‘Amed between Tyre in Lebanon and Acre in Israel) and Cross and Lipiński to Haman or Khamōn, the classical Mount Amanus and modern Nur Mountains, which separate northern Syria from southeastern Cilicia.
Baʿal (בַּעַל) appears about 90 times in the Hebrew Bible in reference to various gods. The priests of the Canaanite Baʿal are mentioned numerous times, most prominently in the First Book of Kings. Many scholars believe that this describes Jezebel's attempt to introduce the worship of the Baʿal of Tyre, Melqart, to the Israelite capital Samaria in the 9th century BCE. Against this, Day argues that Jezebel's Baʿal was more probably Baʿal Shamem, the Lord of the Heavens, a title most often applied to Hadad, who is also often titled just Ba‘al.
1 Kings 18 records an account of a contest between the prophet Elijah and Jezebel's priests. Both sides offered a sacrifice to their respective gods: Ba'al failed to light his followers' sacrifice while Yahweh's heavenly fire burnt Elijah's altar to ashes, even after it had been soaked with water. The observers then followed Elijah's instructions to slay the priests of Baʿal, after which it began to rain, showing Yahweh's mastery over the weather.
The title baʿal was a synonym in some contexts of the Hebrew adon ("Lord") and adonai ("My Lord") still used as aliases of the Lord of Israel Yahweh. According to some scholars, the early Hebrews did use the names Baʿal ("Lord") and Baʿali ("My Lord") in reference to the Lord of Israel, just as Baʿal farther north designated the Lord of Ugarit or Lebanon. This occurred both directly and as the divine element of some Hebrew theophoric names. However, according to others it is not certain that the name Baal was definitely applied to Yahweh in early Israelite history. The component Baal in proper names is mostly applied to worshippers of Baal, or descendants of the worshippers of Baal. Names including the element Baʿal presumably in reference to Yahweh include the judge Gideon (also known as Jerubaʿal, lit. "The Lord Strives"), Saul's son Eshbaʿal ("The Lord is Great"), and David's son Beeliada ("The Lord Knows"). The name Bealiah ("The Lord is Jah"; "Yahweh is Baʿal") combined the two. However John Day states that as far as the names Eshba’al, Meriba’al, and Beeliada (that is Baaliada), are concerned it is not certain whether they simply allude to the Cannanite god Ba’al, or are intended to equate Yahweh with Ba’al, or have no connection to Ba’al.
It was the program of Jezebel, in the 9th century BCE, to introduce into Israel's capital city of Samaria her Phoenician worship of Baal as opposed to the worship of Yahweh that made the name anathema to the Israelites.
At first the name Baal was used by the Jews for their God without discrimination, but as the struggle between the two religions developed, the name Baal was given up by the Israelites as a thing of shame, and even names like Jerubbaal were changed to Jerubbosheth: Hebrew bosheth means "shame".
Eshbaʿal became Ish-bosheth and Meribaʿal became Mephibosheth, but other possibilities also occurred. Beeliada is mentioned renamed as Eliada and Gideon's name Jerubaʿal was mentioned intact but glossed as a mockery of the Canaanite god, implying that he strove in vain. Direct use of Baʿali continued at least as late as the time of the prophet Hosea, who reproached the Israelites for doing so.
Brad E. Kelle has suggested that references to cultic sexual practices in the worship of Baal, in Hosea 2, are evidence of an historical situation in which Israelites were either giving up Yahweh worship for Baal, or blending the two. Hosea's references to sexual acts being metaphors for Israelite "apostasy".
Baʿal Berith ("Lord of the Covenant") was a god worshipped by the Israelites when they "went astray" after the death of Gideon according to the Hebrew Scriptures. The same source relates that Gideon's son Abimelech went to his mother's kin at Shechem and received 70 shekels of silver "from the House of Baʿal Berith" to assist in killing his 70 brothers from Gideon's other wives. An earlier passage had made Shechem the scene of Joshua's covenant between all the tribes of Israel and "El Yahweh, our god of Israel" and a later one describes it as the location of the "House of El Berith". It is thus unclear whether the false worship of the "Baʿalim" being decried is the worship of a new idol or the continued worship of Yahweh, but by means of rites and teachings taking him to be a mere local god within a larger pantheon. The Hebrew Scriptures record the worship of Baʿal threatening Israel from the time of the Judges until the monarchy. The Deuteronomist and the present form of Jeremiah seem to phrase the struggle as monolatry or monotheism against polytheism. Yahweh is frequently identified in the Hebrew scriptures with El Elyon, however, this was after a conflation with El in a process of religious syncretism. ’El (Hebrew: אל) became a generic term meaning "god", as opposed to the name of a worshipped deity, and epithets such as El Shaddai came to be applied to Yahweh alone, while Baal's nature as a storm and weather god became assimilated into Yahweh's own identification with the storm. In the next stage the Yahwistic religion separated itself from its Canaanite heritage, first by rejecting Baal-worship in the 9th century, then through the 8th to 6th centuries with prophetic condemnation of Baal, sun-worship, worship on the "high places", practices pertaining to the dead, and other matters.
Baʿal Zebub (Hebrew: בעל זבוב, lit. "Fly Lord")[h] occurs in the first chapter of the Second Book of Kings as the name of the Philistine god of Ekron. In it, Ahaziah, king of Israel, is said to have consulted the priests of Baʿal Zebub as to whether he would survive the injuries from his recent fall. The prophet Elijah, incensed at this impiety, then foretold that he would die quickly, raining heavenly fire on the soldiers sent to punish him for doing so. Jewish scholars have interpreted the title of "Lord of the Flies" as the Hebrew way of calling Baʿal a pile of dung and his followers vermin, although others argue for a link to power over causing and curing pestilence and thus suitable for Ahaziah's question. The Septuagint renders the name as Baälzeboúb (βααλζεβούβ) and as "Baʿal of Flies" (βααλ μυιαν, Baäl muian). Symmachus the Ebionite rendered it as Beëlzeboúl (Βεελζεβούλ), possibly reflecting its original sense.[i] This has been proposed to have been B‘l Zbl, Ugaritic for "Lord of the Home" or "Lord of the Heavens".[j][k][l]
Outside of Jewish and Christian contexts, the various forms of Baʿal were indifferently rendered in classical sources as Belus (Greek: Βῆλος, Bē̂los). An example is Josephus, who states that Jezebel "built a temple to the god of the Tyrians, which they call Belus"; this describes the Baʿal of Tyre, Melqart. In the interpretatio graeca, Baʿal was usually associated with Jupiter Belus but sometimes connected with Hercules. Herrmann identifies the Demarus or Demarous mentioned by Philo Byblius as Baʿal.
Baʿal Hammon, however, was identified with the Greek Cronos and the Roman Saturn (as the "African Saturn"). He was probably never equated with Melqart, although this assertion appears in older scholarship.
John Milton's 1667 epic Paradise Lost describes the fallen angels collecting around Satan, stating that, though their heavenly names had been "blotted out and ras'd", they would acquire new ones "wandring ore the Earth" as false gods. The "Baalim" and "Ashtaroth" are given as the collective names of the male and female demons (respectively) who came from between the "bordering flood of old Euphrates" and "the Brook that parts Egypt from Syrian ground". "Baal" and derived epithets like "Baalist" were used as slurs during the English Reformation for the Catholic saints and their devotees.
And Elias was most surely of the messengers. He asked his people: 'Do you not fear [God]? Will ye call upon Baal and forsake the best of creators? God is your Lord and the Lord of your fathers, the ancients' But they rejected him, and they will certainly be called up [for punishment], except the sincere and devoted servants of God [among them], and we left [this blessing] for him among generations [to come] in later times, peace be upon Elias.
- Other Baals
- Baal in popular culture
- Baal the demon
- Baʿal Shamem (Lord of the Heavens)
- Baʿal Peʿor (Lord of Mt Peʿor)
- Baʿal Zaphon (Lord of Mt Zaphon)
- Bel and Temple of Bel
- Canaanite religion
- Teshub and Theispas
- Adad and Hadad
- The American pronunciation is usually the same but some speakers prefer variants closer to the original sound, such as /bɑːˈɑːl/ or /ˈbɑːl/.
- Ugaritic: 𐎁𐎓𐎍 baʿalu; Phoenician: 𐤁𐤏𐤋 baʿl; Biblical Hebrew: בעל baʿal, pronounced [baʕal]).
- This cuneiform is identical to the ⟨ 𒂗 ⟩ which is taken as EN in Sumerian texts. There, it has the meaning "high priest" or "lord" and appears in the names of the gods Enki and Enlil.
- In surviving accounts, Baʿal's power over fertility extends only over vegetation. Older scholarship claimed Baʿal controlled human fertility as well, but did so on the basis of misinterpretation or of inscriptions now regarded as dubious. Similarly, 19th-century scholarship treating Baal as a personification of the sun seems to have been badly taken. The astrotheology of Near Eastern deities was an Iron Age development long postdating the origin of religion and, following its development, Bel and Baʿal were associated with the planet Jupiter. The sun was worshipped in Canaan as either the goddess Shapash or the god Shamash.
- Herrmann argues against seeing these separate lineages literally, instead proposing that they describe Baʿal's roles. As a god, he is understood as a child of El, "father of gods", while his fertility aspects connect him to the grain god Dagan.
- The account is patchy and obscure here. Some scholars take some or all of the terms to refer to Litan and in other passages ʿAnat takes credit for destroying the monsters on Baʿal's behalf. Herrmann takes "Šalyaṭu" as a proper name rather than translating it as the "powerful one" or "tyrant".
- This name appears twice in the Legend of Keret discovered at Ugarit. Before this discovery, Nyberg had restored it to the Hebrew texts of Deuteronomy, 1 & 2 Samuel, Isaiah, and Hosea. Following its verification, additional instances have been claimed in the Psalms and in Job.
- "The etymology of Beelzebul has proceeded in several directions. The variant reading Beelzebub (Syriac translators and Jerome) reflects a long-standing tradition of equating Beelzebul with the Philistine deity of the city of Ekron mentioned in 2 Kgs 1:2, 3, 6, 16. Baalzebub (Heb ba˓al zĕbûb) seems to mean “lord of flies” (HALAT, 250, but cf. LXXB baal muian theon akkarōn, “Baal-Fly, god of Akkaron”; Ant 9:2, 1 theon muian)."
- Arndt & al. reverse this, saying Symmachus transcribed Baälzeboúb for a more common Beëlzeboúl.
- "It is more probable that b‘l zbl, which can mean “lord of the (heavenly) dwelling” in Ugaritic, was changed to b‘l zbb to make the divine name an opprobrius epithet. The reading Beelzebul in Mt. 10:25 would then reflect the right form of the name, a wordplay on “master of the house” (Gk oikodespótēs)."
- "An alternative suggested by many is to connect zĕbûl with a noun meaning '(exalted) abode.'"
- "In contemporary Semitic speech it may have been understood as ‘the master of the house’; if so, this phrase could be used in a double sense in Mt. 10:25b."
- "In NT Gk. beelzeboul, beezeboul (Beelzebub in TR and AV) is the prince of the demons (Mt. 12:24, 27; Mk. 3:22; Lk. 11:15, 18f.), identified with Satan (Mt. 12:26; Mk. 3:23, 26; Lk. 11:18)."
- "Besides, Matt 12:24; Mark 3:22; Luke 11:15 use the apposition ἄρχων τῶν δαιμονίων ‘head of the →Demons’."
- "Baal". Oxford English Dictionary (3rd ed.). Oxford University Press. September 2005. Retrieved 26 December 2019. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
- "Baal". Lexico. Oxford University Press and Dictionary.com. Retrieved 26 December 2019.
- "baal". Merriam-Webster Online. Retrieved 26 December 2019.
- "Baal". Webb's Easy Bible Names Pronunciation Guide. 2012.
- De Moor & al. (1987), p. 1.
- Smith (1878), pp. 175–176.
- AYBD (1992), "Baal (Deity)".
- Romans 11:4
- Herrmann (1999a), p. 132.
- Huss (1985), p. 561.
- Oxford English Dictionary (1885), "Baalist, n."
- Pope (2006).
- DULAT (2015), "bʕl (II)".
- Kane (1990), p. 861.
- Strong (1890), H1172.
- Wehr & al. (1976), p. 67.
- Belin, in Gilles Ménage, Dictionnaire étymologique de la langue françoise, 1750. Ménage constructs a derivation of both the "Chaldean" Bel and the Celtic Belin from a supposed word for "ball, sphere", whence "head", and "chief, lord"
- Halpern (2009), p. 64.
- Day (2000), p. 68.
- Ayali-Darshan (2013), p. 652.
- Decker, Roy (2001), "Carthaginian Religion", Ancient/Classical History, New York: About.com, p. 2
- Herrmann (1999a), p. 133.
- Herrmann (1999a), p. 134.
- Herrmann (1999a), pp. 134–135.
- Smith & al. (1899).
- Batuman, Elif (18 December 2014), "The Myth of the Megalith", The New Yorker
- Allen, Spencer L (2015). The Splintered Divine: A Study of Istar, Baal, and Yahweh Divine Names and Divine Multiplicity in the Ancient Near East. p. 216. ISBN 9781614512363.
- Miller (2000), p. 32.
- Herrmann (1999a), p. 135.
- Uehlinger (1999), p. 512.
- DULAT (2015), "šlyṭ".
- Collins (1984), p. 77.
- Deut. 33:12.
- 1 Sam. 2:10.
- 2 Sam. 23:1.
- Isa. 59:18 & 63:7.
- Hos. 7:16.
- Herrmann (1999a), pp. 132–133.
- "Baal | ancient deity". Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved 2017-08-04.
- Moscati (2001), p. 132.
- Lancel (1995), p. 197.
- Lipiński (1992).
- Xella et al. 2013.
- Lancel (1995), p. 195.
- Walbank (1979), p. 47.
- Gibson (1982), p. 39 & 118.
- Cross (1973), p. 26–28.
- Lipiński (1994), p. 207.
- Josephus, Antiquities, 8.13.1.
- BEWR (2006), "Baal".
- Day (2000), p. 75.
- 1 Kings 18
- 2 Kings 23:5.
- 2 Kings 10:22
- Herrmann (1999a), p. 136.
- Ayles (1904), p. 103.
- 1 Chron. 12:5.
- Easton (1893), "Beali′ah".
- Day (2000), p. 72.
- ZPBD (1963).
- 1 Chron. 9:40.
- Judges 6:32.
- Hosea 2:16
- Kelle (2005), p. 137.
- Jgs. 8:33–34.
- Jgs. 9:1–5.
- Josh. 24:1–25.
- Jgs. 9:46.
- Smith (2002), Ch. 2.
- Deut. 4:1–40.
- Jer. 11:12–13.
- Smith 2002, p. 8.
- Smith 2002, p. 8, 135.
- Smith 2002, p. 9.
- Arndt & al. (2000), p. 173.
- Balz & al. (2004), p. 211.
- AYBD (1992), "Beelzebul".
- 2 Kings 1:1–18.
- Kohler (1902).
- Lurker (1987), p. 31.
- Herrmann (1999b).
- Souvay (1907).
- Wex (2005).
- McIntosh (1989).
- Bruce (1996).
- Milton, Paradise Lost, Bk. 1, ll. 419–423.
- Quran 37:123-130.
- Arndt, W.; Danker, F.W.; Bauer, W. (2000), A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, 3rd ed., Chicago: University of Chicago Press
- Ayali-Darshan, Noga (2013), "Baal, Son of Dagan: In Search of Baal's Double Paternity", Journal of the American Oriental Society, Vol. 133, No. 4, pp. 651–657
- Ayles, H.H.B. (1904), A Critical Commentary on Genesis II.4-III.25, Cambridge: J. & C.F. Clay for the Cambridge University Press
- Balz, Horst R.; Schneider, Gerhard (2004), Exegetical Dictionary of the New Testament, Vol. I, Grand Rapids: translated from the German for Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, ISBN 978-0802828033
- Bruce, Frederick Fyvie (1996), "Baal-Zebub, Beelzebul", in Marshall, I. Howard; Millard, Alan R.; Packer, J.I.; Wiseman, Donald J. (eds.), New Bible Dictionary, 3rd ed., Leicester: InterVarsity Press, p. 108, ISBN 978-0830814398
- Collins, John J. (1984), Daniel: with an Introduction to Apocalyptic Literature, Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, ISBN 9780802800206
- Cross, Frank Moore Jr. (1973), Canaanite Myth and Hebrew Epic: Essays in the History of the Religion of Israel, Cambridge: Harvard University Press, ISBN 9780674030084
- Day, John (2000), Yahweh and the Gods and Goddesses of Canaan, Sheffield Academic Press, ISBN 978-1850759867
- De Moor, Johannes Cornelius; Spronk, Klaas (1987), Hoftijzer, J.; Hospers, J.H. (eds.), A Cuneiform Anthology of Religious Texts from Ugarit: Autographed Texts and Glossaries, Leiden: E.J. Brill (Semitic Studies Series №VI), ISBN 90-04-08331-6
- Easton, Matthew George, ed. (1893), Illustrated Bible Dictionary and Treasury of Biblical History, Biography, Geography, Doctrine, and Literature with Numerous Illustrations and Important Chronological Tables and Maps, New York: Harper & Bros.
- Frassetto, Michael, ed. (2006), Britannica Encyclopedia of World Religions, New York: Encyclopædia Britannica, ISBN 978-1-59339-491-2
- Freedman, David Noel, ed. (1992), The Anchor Yale Bible Dictionary, Vol. 1, New York: Doubleday, ISBN 978-0300140019
- Gibson, John Clark Love (1982), Textbook of Syrian Semitic Inscriptions, Vol. III: Phoenician Inscriptions, Oxford: Oxford University Press, ISBN 9780198131991
- Halpern, Baruch (2009), Adams, M.J. (ed.), From Gods to God: The Dynamics of Iron Age Cosmologies, Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck (Ser. Forschungen zum Alten Testament, No. 63), ISBN 978-3-16-149902-9
- Herrmann, Wolfgang (1999a), "Baal", in Toorn, Karel van der; Becking, Bob; Horst, Pieter Willem van der (eds.), Dictionary of Deities and Demons in the Bible, 2nd ed., Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, pp. 132–139
- Herrmann, Wolfgang (1999b), "Baal Zebub", in Toorn, Karel van der; Becking, Bob; Horst, Pieter Willem van der (eds.), Dictionary of Deities and Demons in the Bible, 2nd ed., Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, p. 154
- Huss, Werner (1985), Geschichte der Karthager, Munich: C.H. Beck. (in German)
- Kane, Thomas Leiper (1990), Amharic–English Dictionary, Vol. I, Weisbaden: Otto Harrassowitz, ISBN 978-3-447-02871-4
- Kohler, Kaufmann (1902), "Beelzebub or Beelzebul", in Singer, Isidore; et al. (eds.), The Jewish Encyclopedia, II, New York: Funk & Wagnalls, pp. 629–630
- Kelle, Brad E. (2005), Hosea 2: Metaphor and Rhetoric in Historical Perspective, Society of Biblical Lit, p. 137
- Lancel, Serge (1995), Carthage: A History, Wiley-Blackwell, translated from the French by Antonia Nevill, ISBN 978-1557864680
- Lipiński, Edward (1992), Dictionnaire de la civilisation phenicienne et punique [Dictionary of the Phoenician and Punic Civilization] (in French), ISBN 2-503-50033-1
- Lipiński, Edward (1994), Studies in Aramaic Inscriptions and Onomastics, Vol. II, Orientalia Lovaniensia Analecta, Vol. 57, Leuven: Orientaliste for Peeters Publishers, ISBN 90-6831-610-9
- Lurker, Manfred (1984), Lexicon der Götter und Dämonen [Dictionary of Gods and Demons], Stuttgart: Alfred Krämer Verlag, translated from the German for Routledge in 1987 as The Routledge Dictionary of Gods and Goddesses, Devils and Demons
- McIntosh, Duncan (1989), "Baal-Zebub", in Bromiley, Geoffrey W. (ed.), International Standard Bible Encyclopedia, Rev. ed., Vol. I, Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, p. 381
- Miller, Patrick (2000), Israelite Religion and Biblical Theology: Collected Essays, Continuum Int'l Publishing Group, ISBN 1-84127-142-X
- Moscati, Sabatino (2001), The Phoenicians, Tauris, ISBN 1-85043-533-2
- Olmo Lete, Gregorio del; Sanmartin, Joaquin; Watson, Wilfred G.E., eds. (2015), Diccionario de la Lengua Ugarítica, 3rd ed., Leiden: translated from the Spanish for E.J. Brill as A Dictionary of the Ugaritic Language in the Alphabetic Tradition (Ser. Handbuch der Orientalistik [Handbook of Oriental Studies], Vol. 112), ISBN 978-90-04-28864-5
- Pope, Marvin H. (2006), "Baal Worship", in Skolnik, Fred; Berenbaum, Michael; Baskin, Judith (eds.), Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., Vol. III, New York: Thomas Gale, ISBN 978-0028659282
- Schniedewind, William; Hunt, Joel (2007), A Primer on Ugaritic: Language, Culture, and Literature, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, ISBN 978-1139466981
- Smith, Mark S. (2002), The Early History of God: Yahweh and the Other Deities in Ancient Israel, Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing
- Smith, William Robertson; Moore, George Foot (1899), "Baal", in Cheyne, Thomas Keith; Black, John Sutherland (eds.), Encyclopædia Biblica, Vol. I, New York: Macmillan, pp. 401–403
- Smith, William Robertson (1878), , in Baynes, T.S. (ed.), Encyclopædia Britannica, 3 (9th ed.), New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, pp. 175–176
- Souvay, Charles (1907), "Baal, Baalim", Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. II, New York: Robert Appleton Co.
- Strong, James (1890), The Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible, Cincinnati: Jennings & Graham
- Tenney, Merrill C.; Barabas, Stevan; DeVisser, Peter, eds. (1963), The Zondervan Pictorial Bible Dictionary, Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House, ISBN 978-0310235606
- Uehlinger, C. (1999), "Leviathan", in Toorn, Karel van der; Becking, Bob; Horst, Pieter Willem van der (eds.), Dictionary of Deities and Demons in the Bible, 2nd ed., Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, pp. 511–515
- Walbank, Frank William (1979), A Historical Commentary on Polybius, Vol. 2, Oxford: Clarendon Press
- Wehr, Hans; Cowan, J. Milton (1976), A Dictionary of Modern Written Arabic, Ithaca: Spoken Language Services, ISBN 0879500018
- Wex, Michael (2005), Born to Kvetch, New York: St Martin's Press, ISBN 0-312-30741-1
- Xella, Paolo; Quinn, Josephine; Melchiorri, Valentina; Van Domellen, Peter (2013), "Cemetery or sacrifice? Infant burials at the Carthage Tophet: Phoenician bones of contention", Antiquity, Vol. 87, No. 338, pp. 1199–1207
- Cleghorn, T.L.; Rugg, N.M. (2011), Comprehensive Articulatory Phonetics: A Tool for Mastering the World's Languages, 2nd ed., ISBN 978-1-4507-8190-9
- Smith, M.S. (1994), The Ugaritic Baal Cycle, Vol. I, Leiden: E.J. Brill, ISBN 978-90-04-09995-1
- Smith, M.S.; Pitard, W. (2009), The Ugaritic Baal Cycle, Vol. II, Leiden: E.J. Brill, ISBN 978-90-04-15348-6
- New International Encyclopedia. 1905. .
- Jewish Encyclopedia (1901–1906) "Ba'al", "Ba'al and Ba'al Worship", "Baal-Berith", "Baal-Peor", "Baalim", "Astarte Worship among the Hebrews", &c., Jewish Encyclopedia, New York: Funk & Wagnalls