C/1807 R1

Summary

C/1807 R1
Basi Revolt.jpg
The Great Comet of 1807 seen from the Philippines, as depicted by Esteban Villanueva during the Basi Revolt
Discovery
Discovered bythe Augustinian monk Parisi at Castrogiovanni[1]
Alternative
designations
Great Comet of 1807
Orbital characteristics A
Epoch2381313.7389
1807-Sep-19.2389[2]
Aphelion285.8 AU[2]
Perihelion0.6461 AU[2]
Semi-major axis143.2012 AU
Eccentricity0.9955[2]
Orbital period~1714 a
Inclination63.1762°[2]

C/1807 R1, also known as the Great Comet of 1807, is a long-period comet. It was visible to naked-eye observers in the northern hemisphere from early September 1807 to late December, and is ranked among the great comets due to its exceptional brightness.

Discovery

Artist’s depiction of the western sky slightly after sundown on 9 September 1807 in Sicily (view looking west over the Mediterranean)

Its discovery is often credited to the Augustinian monk P. Reggente Parisi[1][3][4] at Castrogiovanni in Sicily. He recorded observing the comet very close to the horizon in the early twilight of 9 September 1807, not far from the equally bright star Spica: at that time the planets Venus, Mars and Saturn were also near the comet.[5] Moonlight interfered with observations for the following week and thanks to his favorable southerly location, Parisi might have been able to make his discovery several days before a number of other observers in Europe independently discovered the comet.[6]

Orbital data points suggest that the comet should have been first discovered by the unassisted eye in the southern hemisphere several weeks before it became visible in the northern hemisphere; however there are no such historical reports. In Australia the comet should have been visible during all of August in the early evening twilight on the western horizon with a brightness approaching magnitude 1.[7]

Observations

Jean-Louis Pons, at Marseille, saw the comet in evening twilight on 21st September; shortly afterwards his colleague Jacques-Joseph Thulis (1768–1810) made the first positional determination for the comet in terms of the celestial coordinate system.[8] Dunbar, in America, noted that the comet was first seen there "about the 20th September" and commented that the surveyor Seth Pease (1764–1819)[9] began making observations on the 22nd.[10] On September 20th the comet reached a brightness between magnitude 1 and 2.[11]

In the following 10 days the comet was independently discovered by Jacques Vidal and Honoré Flaugergues in France, Edward Pigott in England, Johann Sigismund Gottfried Huth and Johann Friedrich Eule in Germany, and Gonzalez in Spain. The comet was too observed on the 26th September by Francisco José de Caldas in New Granada (Colombia).[12] Vidal estimated the length of the comet’s tail to be between 7° and 8° in length.[13]

Near the end of September, on its journey away from the Sun, the comet made its closest approach to Earth; it was visible to the naked eye throughout the month of October. On October 1 Johann Elert Bode reported a tail length of 5°. On October 4 Huth reported that the tail had split into a straight, 6°-degree long tail and a shorter, curved tail. Both tails were also seen on October 20 when Heinrich Wilhelm Olbers noted that the two tails were separated by 1.5°; the more northerly tail was very narrow, thin and straight and about 10° long, while the more southerly tail was broad, short and about 4.5° long.

A few days later, the two tails could no longer be distinguished from each other; in Natchez, Mississippi, Dunbar saw on October 24 only a single tail, which had a length of 2.7°. At the University of Göttingen, Johann Hieronymus Schroeter made accurate observational measurements of the comet from 4 October 1807 to 18 February 1808.[14] The comet was observed from HMS Buffalo by Captain Philip Gidley King at Lat 15 degrees 4 minutes, Long 28 degrees 52 mins. "Mon 5th Oct. A remarkable star seen for the 2nd time. It appeared from the West and had a bright luminous tail and considerable magnitude".[15]

In November and December the comet was still visible to the naked eye, but its brightness had steadily diminished and by the end of November the tail was difficult to discern. On November 20 William Herschel estimated the length of the tail to be 2.5°, but in the beginning of December he could identify a short tail only in large refractor.

Amongst the observers of the comet was an elderly Charles Messier, who noted that "the comet became very beautiful, and stayed beautiful during a large number of days [...] it was marked in the sky by a nucleus of great luminosity which it enveloped, and from which came out a very clear, very extended tail".[16] Despite failing eyesight, Messier was able to make several telescopic observations of the comet.[17]

From January 1808 there were no further naked-eye observations. Telescopic sightings of the comet were made on February 19 by Olbers, on February 24 by Friedrich Wilhelm Bessel, and on February 28, after a long search, by Dunbar. The final telescopic observation was made by Vincent Wisniewsky in Saint Petersburg on 27 March 1808.[18]

Orbit

Using observations over 187 days Bessel computed an elongated orbit inclined about 63° to the ecliptic.[2] At perihelion, which occurred on 19 September 1807 the comet was about .646 AU the Sun. The comet was on September 11 about .775 AU from Venus and on September 15 about .836 AU from Mars. On September 26 the comet made its closet approach to Earth at a distance of about 1.15 AU; for a great comet this distance is unusually large — only two other known great comets failed to come closer than 1 AU to Earth — namely, the Great Comet of 1811 and Comet Hale-Bopp.[5]

At the time of the discovery of C/1881 K1, the Great Comet of 1881, its discoverer John Tebbutt initially considered the possibility that it was a return of the 1807 comet due to apparent orbital similarities between the two.

Scientific importance

John Bull making observations on the Comet

In October 1807 Bode, Johann Karl Burckhardt and Francis Triesnecker calculated estimates of a parabolic orbit for the comet. Initially Bessel also calculated a parabolic orbit, but additional observations enabled him to calculate an elliptic orbit. Since this estimate of an elliptic orbit still did not agree with the observations to Bessel's satisfaction, he developed a novel method for calculating the orbital elements. Bessel's method took into account the changing gravitational influences of the Sun and planets near to the comet and made better use of the observational data by means of a least squares estimation technique developed a few years earlier by Carl Friedrich Gauss.

For this comet there were observational data for over six months and thus for a significant part of the cometary orbit Bessel's calculated predictions could be compared to the observations. The great comet of 1807 is the first long-period comet (other than Halley's comet, which was already known to be periodic) for which there is empirical verification that it moves in an elliptical, and not in a parabolic, orbit.[19]

References

  1. ^ a b Hind, J. Russell (1852). "1807. The great comet of this year". The comets: a descriptive treatise upon those bodies. London: John W. Parker and Son. p. 154.
  2. ^ a b c d e f "NASA JPL Small-Body Database Browser: C/1807 R1".
  3. ^ Lynn, W. T. (1902). "Edward Piggott and the Comet of 1807". The Observatory. 25 (322): 336–337. Bibcode:1902Obs....25..336L.
  4. ^ Cacciatore, N. (1808) Della cometa apparsa in settembre del 1807, p.9
  5. ^ a b Bryant, Greg. "Bright Comets Of The Last Two Centuries - Part I".
  6. ^ G. W. Kronk: Cometography: A Catalog of Comets, Volume 2. 1800–1899. Cambridge University Press, 2003, ISBN 0-521-58505-8, pp. 10–14.
  7. ^ G. W. Kronk: Cometography: A Catalog of Comets, Volume 2. 1800–1899. Cambridge University Press, 2003, ISBN 0-521-58505-8, pp. 10–14.
  8. ^ G. W. Kronk: Cometography: A Catalog of Comets, Volume 2. 1800–1899. Cambridge University Press, 2003, ISBN 0-521-58505-8, pp. 10–14.
  9. ^ Encyclopedia of Cleveland History: PEASE, SETH
  10. ^ Dunbar, W. "Some Observations in the Comet of 1807-8" in Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, 6 (1809), 368
  11. ^ Donald K. Yeomans. "NASA JPL Solar System Dynamics: Great Comets in History".
  12. ^ Portilla, José Gregorio (2017). "Caldas y el gran cometa de 1807". Revista de la Academia Colombiana de Ciencias Exactas, Físicas y Naturales. 41 (159): 244–252. doi:10.18257/raccefyn.449.
  13. ^ G. W. Kronk: Cometography: A Catalog of Comets, Volume 2. 1800–1899. Cambridge University Press, 2003, ISBN 0-521-58505-8, pp. 10–14.
  14. ^ J. H. Schroeter: Beobachtungen des groſsen Cometen von 1807. Göttingen 1811.
  15. ^ Captain's log held at National Archives, Kew, England ADM51/1694
  16. ^ Grego, P. (2013) Blazing a Ghostly Trail: ISON and Great Comets of the Past and Future, Practical Astronomy, p.106
  17. ^ Grego (2013) p.107
  18. ^ G. W. Kronk: Cometography: A Catalog of Comets, Volume 2. 1800–1899. Cambridge University Press, 2003, ISBN 0-521-58505-8, pp. 10–14.
  19. ^ F. W. Bessel: Untersuchungen über die scheinbare und wahre Bahn des im Jahre 1807 erschienenen grossen Kometen. Königsberg 1810.

External links

  • Media related to C/1807 R1 at Wikimedia Commons