Evermore contains the following tales:

1. "Introduction", by James Robert Smith and Stephen Mark Rainey
2. "All Beauty Sleeps", by Joel Lane
3. "The Clockwork Horror", by F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre
4. "The Impelled", by Gary Fry
5. "The Resurrections of Fortunato", by John Morressy
6. "They Call Me Eddie", by Rick Hautala & Thomas F. Monteleone
7. "Cloud by Night", by Melanie Tem
8. "Poe 103", by Ken Goldman
9. "From the Wall, a Whisper", by Kealan Patrick Burke
10. "When It Was Moonlight", by Manly Wade Wellman
11. "In Articulo Mortis", by Trey R. Baker
12. "Night Writing", by Charlee Jacob
13. "Of Persephone, Poe, and the Whisperer", by Tom Piccirilli
14. "An Author and His Character", by Vincent Starrett
15. "The Masque of Edgar Allan Poe", by Steve Rasnic Tem
16. "The White Cat", by Fred Chappell
17. Evermore Contributor Bios

• Edgar Allan Poe in popular culture