Judge Dredd is a light gun game set in the 22nd century, where Judge Dredd fights an ex-judge prison escapee, who kidnapped the mayor, and his army of merciless androids.^[3][4][5] The gameplay is similar to Area 51 and Maximum Force with some elements from Time Crisis, in that the game's full motion video is integrated with the action.^[5]

The PlayStation version was almost overwhelmingly panned by critics. The complaints were numerous and varied from review to review, but some of the more common ones were that the cluttered screen and confusing backgrounds make it unfairly difficult to spot enemies,^{[7][2][11][13][14]} the targeting cursor lags behind where the gun is actually aimed,^[7][11][4] and enemies take multiple hits too kill, making it almost impossible to get through some sections without getting hit.^{[7][2][11][13]} IGN's Douglass C. Perry also found the level designs poorly paced, with an imbalance between swarms of enemies overwhelming the player and dull stretches of waiting for something to shoot.^[11] PSM denounced the lack of sound marking when a player is hit or even loses a life, pointing out, "This means that no matter how well you do, the game will leave you confused and frustrated when it ends."^[13] A number of critics described Judge Dredd as a third-rate Area 51 clone.^[7][11][13]

Most critics derided the game's story,^[7][2][13] though Perry instead praised it, saying even the awfulness of the rest of the game did not prevent him from enjoying the full motion video (FMV).^[11] Next Generation also praised it, saying it features "some of the clearest and most vibrant video ever to grace a PlayStation game", though they expressed disappointment that the villain of the story, Judge Roy Bean, does not appear as a boss, with the climactic battle instead being played out in a cutscene.^[4] Jeff Gerstmann, reviewing the game for GameSpot, fell in line with the majority opinion on the FMV sequences, remarking, "It looks like the Judge's outfits were made by spraying some gold paint onto cardboard, and the acting is laughably pathetic."^[2] Gerstmann and Electronic Gaming Monthly (EGM) reviewer John Ricciardi both found the licensing questionable, questioning whether a significant Judge Dredd fan base even exists,^[7][2] while Perry lamented that the Judge Dredd movie and video games were giving a bad image to the comic book series, which he felt was "still great".^[11]

The only positive review came from Game Informer, which said, "The story of Judge Dredd is revealed through FMV, but this Dredd is no Sly Stallone. In fact, this Dredd is even more of a dork. Other than that, Activision's new light gun shooter is solid."^[8]

William Schiffmann for the Sun Journal of Lewiston, Maine, said that "if you like shooting gallery games, this is a fine example of the genre." However, he added that the lack of randomization of level designs makes light gun shooters in general not worth buying.^[14] PSM summed up, "Levels are a chore at best, totally devoid of anything that resembles skill. In fact, we've found that the best way to beat a level is to just make sure you find all the hidden health."^[13] All four members of EGM's "review crew" said even light gun enthusiasts would not enjoy the game, and in its "best feature" slot they wrote "Hmmm... Can't think of one..."^[7] Gerstmann similarly advised, "No matter how strong your craving for a gun game may be, just wait this one out."^[2]

• Judge Dredd at the Killer List of Videogames
• Judge Dredd at MobyGames