Min-entropy

Summary

The min-entropy, in information theory, is the smallest of the Rényi family of entropies, corresponding to the most conservative way of measuring the unpredictability of a set of outcomes, as the negative logarithm of the probability of the most likely outcome. The various Rényi entropies are all equal for a uniform distribution, but measure the unpredictability of a nonuniform distribution in different ways. The min-entropy is never greater than the ordinary or Shannon entropy (which measures the average unpredictability of the outcomes) and that in turn is never greater than the Hartley or max-entropy, defined as the logarithm of the number of outcomes with nonzero probability.

As with the classical Shannon entropy and its quantum generalization, the von Neumann entropy, one can define a conditional version of min-entropy. The conditional quantum min-entropy is a one-shot, or conservative, analog of conditional quantum entropy.

To interpret a conditional information measure, suppose Alice and Bob were to share a bipartite quantum state . Alice has access to system and Bob to system . The conditional entropy measures the average uncertainty Bob has about Alice's state upon sampling from his own system. The min-entropy can be interpreted as the distance of a state from a maximally entangled state.

This concept is useful in quantum cryptography, in the context of privacy amplification (See for example [1]).

Definition for classical distributions edit

If   is a classical finite probability distribution, its min-entropy can be defined as[2]

 
One way to justify the name of the quantity is to compare it with the more standard definition of entropy, which reads  , and can thus be written concisely as the expectation value of   over the distribution. If instead of taking the expectation value of this quantity we take its minimum value, we get precisely the above definition of  .

Definition for quantum states edit

A natural way to define a "min-entropy" for quantum states is to leverage the simple observation that quantum states result in probability distributions when measured in some basis. There is however the added difficulty that a single quantum state can result in infinitely many possible probability distributions, depending on how it is measured. A natural path is then, given a quantum state  , to still define   as  , but this time defining   as the maximum possible probability that can be obtained measuring  , maximizing over all possible projective measurements.

Formally, this would provide the definition

 
where we are maximizing over the set of all projective measurements  ,   represent the measurement outcomes in the POVM formalism, and   is therefore the probability of observing the  -th outcome when the measurement is  .

A more concise method to write the double maximization is to observe that any element of any POVM is a Hermitian operator such that  , and thus we can equivalently directly maximize over these to get

 
In fact, this maximization can be performed explicitly and the maximum is obtained when   is the projection onto (any of) the largest eigenvalue(s) of  . We thus get yet another expression for the min-entropy as:
 
remembering that the operator norm of a Hermitian positive semidefinite operator equals its largest eigenvalue.

Conditional entropies edit

Let   be a bipartite density operator on the space  . The min-entropy of   conditioned on   is defined to be

 

where the infimum ranges over all density operators   on the space  . The measure   is the maximum relative entropy defined as

 

The smooth min-entropy is defined in terms of the min-entropy.

 

where the sup and inf range over density operators   which are  -close to  . This measure of  -close is defined in terms of the purified distance

 

where   is the fidelity measure.

These quantities can be seen as generalizations of the von Neumann entropy. Indeed, the von Neumann entropy can be expressed as

 

This is called the fully quantum asymptotic equipartition theorem.[3] The smoothed entropies share many interesting properties with the von Neumann entropy. For example, the smooth min-entropy satisfy a data-processing inequality:[4]

 

Operational interpretation of smoothed min-entropy edit

Henceforth, we shall drop the subscript   from the min-entropy when it is obvious from the context on what state it is evaluated.

Min-entropy as uncertainty about classical information edit

Suppose an agent had access to a quantum system   whose state   depends on some classical variable  . Furthermore, suppose that each of its elements   is distributed according to some distribution  . This can be described by the following state over the system  .

 

where   form an orthonormal basis. We would like to know what the agent can learn about the classical variable  . Let   be the probability that the agent guesses   when using an optimal measurement strategy

 

where   is the POVM that maximizes this expression. It can be shown[citation needed] that this optimum can be expressed in terms of the min-entropy as

 

If the state   is a product state i.e.   for some density operators   and  , then there is no correlation between the systems   and  . In this case, it turns out that  

Min-entropy as overlap with the maximally entangled state edit

The maximally entangled state   on a bipartite system   is defined as

 

where   and   form an orthonormal basis for the spaces   and   respectively. For a bipartite quantum state  , we define the maximum overlap with the maximally entangled state as

 

where the maximum is over all CPTP operations   and   is the dimension of subsystem  . This is a measure of how correlated the state   is. It can be shown that  . If the information contained in   is classical, this reduces to the expression above for the guessing probability.

Proof of operational characterization of min-entropy edit

The proof is from a paper by König, Schaffner, Renner in 2008.[5] It involves the machinery of semidefinite programs.[6] Suppose we are given some bipartite density operator  . From the definition of the min-entropy, we have

 

This can be re-written as

 

subject to the conditions

 
 

We notice that the infimum is taken over compact sets and hence can be replaced by a minimum. This can then be expressed succinctly as a semidefinite program. Consider the primal problem

 
 
 

This primal problem can also be fully specified by the matrices   where   is the adjoint of the partial trace over  . The action of   on operators on   can be written as

 

We can express the dual problem as a maximization over operators   on the space   as

 
 
 

Using the Choi–Jamiołkowski isomorphism, we can define the channel   such that

 

where the bell state is defined over the space  . This means that we can express the objective function of the dual problem as

 
 

as desired.

Notice that in the event that the system   is a partly classical state as above, then the quantity that we are after reduces to

 

We can interpret   as a guessing strategy and this then reduces to the interpretation given above where an adversary wants to find the string   given access to quantum information via system  .

See also edit

References edit

  1. ^ Vazirani, Umesh; Vidick, Thomas (29 September 2014). "Fully Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution". Physical Review Letters. 113 (14): 140501. arXiv:1210.1810. Bibcode:2014PhRvL.113n0501V. doi:10.1103/physrevlett.113.140501. ISSN 0031-9007. PMID 25325625. S2CID 119299119.
  2. ^ König, Robert; Renner, Renato; Schaffner, Christian (2009). "The Operational Meaning of Min- and Max-Entropy". IEEE Transactions on Information Theory. 55 (9). Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE): 4337–4347. arXiv:0807.1338. doi:10.1109/tit.2009.2025545. ISSN 0018-9448. S2CID 17160454.
  3. ^ Tomamichel, Marco; Colbeck, Roger; Renner, Renato (2009). "A Fully Quantum Asymptotic Equipartition Property". IEEE Transactions on Information Theory. 55 (12). Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE): 5840–5847. arXiv:0811.1221. doi:10.1109/tit.2009.2032797. ISSN 0018-9448. S2CID 12062282.
  4. ^ Renato Renner, "Security of Quantum Key Distribution", Ph.D. Thesis, Diss. ETH No. 16242 arXiv:quant-ph/0512258
  5. ^ König, Robert; Renner, Renato; Schaffner, Christian (2009). "The Operational Meaning of Min- and Max-Entropy". IEEE Transactions on Information Theory. 55 (9). Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE): 4337–4347. arXiv:0807.1338. doi:10.1109/tit.2009.2025545. ISSN 0018-9448. S2CID 17160454.
  6. ^ John Watrous, Theory of quantum information, Fall 2011, course notes, https://cs.uwaterloo.ca/~watrous/CS766/LectureNotes/07.pdf