New York's 17th congressional district

Summary

New York's 17th congressional district is a congressional district for the United States House of Representatives located in Southern New York. It includes all of Rockland County and Putnam County, as well as most of Northern Westchester County, and portions of southern Dutchess County. It is represented by Republican Mike Lawler. It was one of 18 districts that would have voted for Joe Biden in the 2020 presidential election had they existed in their current configuration while being won or held by a Republican in 2022.

New York's 17th congressional district
Map
Map
Interactive map of district boundaries
Representative
  Mike Lawler
RPearl River
Distribution
  • 98.40% urban
  • 1.60% rural
Population (2022)771,464
Median household
income
$115,661[1]
Ethnicity
Cook PVID+3[2]

Mondaire Jones was first elected in 2020 to succeed the retiring Representative Nita Lowey.[3] In the aftermath of the 2020 redistricting cycle, 18th district incumbent Sean Patrick Maloney announced his intention to run in the new 17th district instead of his existing seat; Jones subsequently opted to run in the 10th district to avoid a primary fight. However, Maloney lost to Republican Mike Lawler in the general election; Lawler subsequently became the first of his party to win this seat since 1981.[4] Lawler's victory gained significant attention due to Maloney's position as chairman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee; Maloney became the first chairman in over 40 years to lose reelection.[5]

The district has a significant Jewish population, including conservative Hasidic communities in Rockland County.[6][7]

Recent statewide election results edit

Year Office Results
1992 President Clinton 75–19%
1996 President Clinton 85–11%
2000 President Gore 69–27%
2004 President Kerry 67–33%
2008 President Obama 72–28%
2012 President Obama 57–41%
2016 President H. Clinton 52–39%
2020 President Biden 60–39%

History edit

 
The district from 2003 to 2013
 
The district from 2013 to 2023

2023–present:

All of Putnam, Rockland
Parts of Dutchess, Westchester

2013–2023: map

All of Rockland
Part of Westchester

2003–2013:

Parts of Bronx, Rockland, Westchester.

1993–2003:

Parts of Bronx, Westchester.

1983–1993:

Parts of Bronx, Manhattan.

1973–1983:

All of Staten Island.
Parts of Manhattan.

1913–1973:

Parts of Manhattan.

1843–1853:

Montgomery

Various New York districts have been numbered "17" over the years, including areas in New York City and various parts of upstate New York. From 2003-2013, the 17th district encompassed portions of the Bronx, Westchester County, and Rockland County. It included the neighborhoods of Norwood, Riverdale, Wakefield, Williamsbridge, and Woodlawn in the Bronx; the city of Mount Vernon and parts of Yonkers in Westchester; and Monsey, Nanuet, Pearl River, Orangetown, Sparkill, Spring Valley, Haverstraw, and Suffern in Rockland County.

List of members representing the district edit

The District was historically the East Side Manhattan district (known as the "silk stocking district" for the wealth of its constituents). In the 1970s it was a Staten Island seat. It became the west side Manhattan seat in the 1980s. It became a Bronx-based seat in the 1992 remap and was shifted north into Rockland county in 2002 to absorb terrain from the deconstruction of the old 20th district.

Previously the 19th district covered much of the Bronx portion of the seat in the 1980s; while in the 1970s the 23rd district covered most of the Bronx area.

1803–1833: one seat edit

Representative Party Years Cong
ress
Electoral history Location
District established March 4, 1803
 
Oliver Phelps
(Canandaigua)
Democratic-Republican March 4, 1803 –
March 3, 1805
8th Elected in 1802.
[data missing]
1803–1809
[data missing]
 
Silas Halsey
(Ovid)
Democratic-Republican March 4, 1805 –
March 3, 1807
9th Elected in 1804.
Lost re-election.
John Harris
(Aurelius)
Democratic-Republican March 4, 1807 –
March 3, 1809
10th Elected in 1806.
Lost re-election.
District inactive March 4, 1809 –
March 3, 1813
11th
12th
 
William S. Smith
(Lebanon)
Federalist March 4, 1813 –
March 3, 1815
13th Elected in 1812.
Re-elected in 1814 but did not take or claim the seat.
1813–1823
Herkimer County, except the Town of Danube; and Madison County.
Vacant March 4, 1815 –
December 13, 1815
14th
 
Westel Willoughby Jr.
(Herkimer)
Democratic-Republican December 13, 1815 –
March 3, 1817
Successfully contested Smith's election.
[data missing]
 
Thomas H. Hubbard
(Hamilton)
Democratic-Republican March 4, 1817 –
March 3, 1819
15th Elected in 1816.
[data missing]
Aaron Hackley Jr.
(Herkimer)
Democratic-Republican March 4, 1819 –
March 3, 1821
16th Elected in 1818.
[data missing]
Vacant March 4, 1821 –
December 3, 1821
17th Elections were held in April 1821. It is unclear when results were announced or credentials issued.
 
Thomas H. Hubbard
(Hamilton)
Democratic-Republican December 3, 1821 –
March 3, 1823
Elected in 1821.
[data missing]
 
John W. Taylor
(Ballston Spa)
Democratic-Republican March 4, 1823 –
March 3, 1825
18th
19th
20th
21st
22nd
Redistricted from 11th district and re-elected in 1822.
Re-elected in 1824.
Re-elected in 1826.
Re-elected in 1828.
Re-elected in 1830.
Lost re-election.
Saratoga County
Anti-Jacksonian March 4, 1825 –
March 3, 1833

1833–1843: two seats edit

From 1833 to 1843, two seats were apportioned to the 17th district, elected at-large on a general ticket.

Seat A edit

Representative Party Years Cong
ress
Electoral history
 
Samuel Beardsley
(Utica)
Jacksonian March 4, 1833 –
March 29, 1836
23rd
24th
Redistricted from 14th district and re-elected in 1832.
Re-elected in 1834.
Resigned to become circuit judge.
Vacant March 29, 1836 –
November 9, 1836
24th [data missing]
Rutger B. Miller
(Utica)
Jacksonian November 9, 1836 –
March 3, 1837
Elected to finish Beardsley's term.
[data missing]
 
Henry A. Foster
(Rome)
Democratic March 4, 1837 –
March 3, 1839
25th Elected in 1836.
[data missing]
David P. Brewster
(Oswego)
Democratic March 4, 1839 –
March 3, 1843
26th
27th
Elected in 1838.
Re-elected in 1840.
[data missing]

Seat B edit

Representative Party Years Cong
ress
Electoral history
 
Joel Turrill
(Oswego)
Jacksonian March 4, 1833 –
March 3, 1837
23rd
24th
Elected in 1832.
Re-elected in 1834.
[data missing]
 
Abraham P. Grant
(Oswego)
Democratic March 4, 1837 –
March 3, 1839
25th Elected in 1836.
[data missing]
 
John G. Floyd
(Utica)
Democratic March 4, 1839 –
March 3, 1843
26th
27th
Elected in 1838.
Re-elected in 1840.
[data missing]

1843–present: one seat edit

Representative Party Years Cong
ress
Electoral history District location
 
Charles S. Benton
(Mohawk)
Democratic March 4, 1843 –
March 3, 1847
28th
29th
Elected in 1842.
Re-elected in 1844.
[data missing]
George Petrie
(Little Falls)
Independent Democrat March 4, 1847 –
March 3, 1849
30th Elected in 1846.
[data missing]
Henry P. Alexander
(Little Falls)
Whig March 4, 1849 –
March 3, 1851
31st Elected in 1848.
[data missing]
 
Alexander H. Buell
(Fairfield)
Democratic March 4, 1851 –
January 29, 1853
32nd Elected in 1850.
Died.
Vacant January 29, 1853 –
March 3, 1853
[data missing]
 
Bishop Perkins
(Ogdensburg)
Democratic March 4, 1853 –
March 3, 1855
33rd Elected in 1852.
[data missing]
 
Francis E. Spinner
(Mohawk)
Democratic March 4, 1855 –
March 3, 1857
34th
35th
36th
Elected in 1854.
Re-elected in 1856.
Re-elected in 1858.
[data missing]
Republican March 4, 1857 –
March 3, 1861
 
Socrates N. Sherman
(Ogdensburg)
Republican March 4, 1861 –
March 3, 1863
37th Elected in 1860.
[data missing]
 
Calvin T. Hulburd
(Brasher Falls)
Republican March 4, 1863 –
March 3, 1869
38th
39th
40th
Elected in 1862.
Re-elected in 1864.
Re-elected in 1866.
[data missing]
 
William A. Wheeler
(Malone)
Republican March 4, 1869 –
March 3, 1873
41st
42nd
Elected in 1868.
Re-elected in 1870.
Redistricted to 18th district.
 
Robert S. Hale
(Elizabethtown)
Republican March 4, 1873 –
March 3, 1875
43rd Elected in 1872.
[data missing]
 
Martin I. Townsend
(Troy)
Republican March 4, 1875 –
March 3, 1879
44th
45th
Elected in 1874.
Re-elected in 1876.
[data missing]
 
Walter A. Wood
(Hoosick Falls)
Republican March 4, 1879 –
March 3, 1883
46th
47th
Elected in 1878.
Re-elected in 1880.
[data missing]
 
Henry G. Burleigh
(Whitehall)
Republican March 4, 1883 –
March 3, 1885
48th Elected in 1882.
Redistricted to 18th district
 
James G. Lindsley
(Rondout)
Republican March 4, 1885 –
March 3, 1887
49th Elected in 1884.
[data missing]
 
Stephen T. Hopkins
(Catskill)
Republican March 4, 1887 –
March 3, 1889
50th Elected in 1886.
[data missing]
 
Charles J. Knapp
(Deposit)
Republican March 4, 1889 –
March 3, 1891
51st Elected in 1888.
[data missing]
 
Isaac N. Cox
(Ellenville)
Democratic March 4, 1891 –
March 3, 1893
52nd Elected in 1890.
[data missing]
 
Francis Marvin
(Port Jervis)
Republican March 4, 1893 –
March 3, 1895
53rd Elected in 1892.
[data missing]
 
Benjamin B. Odell Jr.
(Newburgh)
Republican March 4, 1895 –
March 3, 1899
54th
55th
Elected in 1894.
Re-elected in 1896.
[data missing]
 
Arthur S. Tompkins
(Nyack)
Republican March 4, 1899 –
March 3, 1903
56th
57th
Elected in 1898.
Re-elected in 1900.
[data missing]
 
Francis E. Shober
(New York)
Democratic March 4, 1903 –
March 3, 1905
58th Elected in 1902.
[data missing]
 
William S. Bennet
(New York)
Republican March 4, 1905 –
March 3, 1911
59th
60th
61st
Elected in 1904.
Re-elected in 1906.
Re-elected in 1908.
[data missing]
 
Henry George Jr.
(New York)
Democratic March 4, 1911 –
March 3, 1913
62nd Elected in 1910.
Redistricted to 21st district
 
John F. Carew
(New York)
Democratic March 4, 1913 –
March 3, 1919
63rd
64th
65th
Elected in 1912.
Re-elected in 1914.
Re-elected in 1916
Redistricted to 18th district
 
Herbert Pell
(New York)
Democratic March 4, 1919 –
March 3, 1921
66th Elected in 1918.
[data missing]
 
Ogden L. Mills
(New York)
Republican March 4, 1921 –
March 3, 1927
67th
68th
69th
Elected in 1920.
Re-elected in 1922.
Re-elected in 1924.
[data missing]
 
William W. Cohen
(New York)
Democratic March 4, 1927 –
March 3, 1929
70th Elected in 1926.
[data missing]
 
Ruth B. Pratt
(New York)
Republican March 4, 1929 –
March 3, 1933
71st
72nd
Elected in 1928.
Re-elected in 1930.
[data missing]
 
Theodore A. Peyser
(New York)
Democratic March 4, 1933 –
August 8, 1937
73rd
74th
75th
Elected in 1932.
Re-elected in 1934.
Re-elected in 1936.
Died.
Vacant August 8, 1937 –
November 2, 1937
75th [data missing]
 
Bruce F. Barton
(New York)
Republican November 2, 1937 –
January 3, 1941
75th
76th
Elected to finish Peyser's term.
Re-elected in 1938.
[data missing]
 
Kenneth F. Simpson
(New York)
Republican January 3, 1941 –
January 25, 1941
77th Elected in 1940.
Died.
Vacant January 29, 1941 –
March 11, 1941
[data missing]
 
Joseph C. Baldwin
(New York)
Republican March 11, 1941 –
January 3, 1947
77th
78th
79th
Elected to finish Simpson's term.
Re-elected in 1942.
Re-elected in 1944.
[data missing]
 
Frederic R. Coudert Jr.
(New York)
Republican January 3, 1947 –
January 3, 1959
80th
81st
82nd
83rd
84th
85th
Elected in 1946.
Re-elected in 1948.
Re-elected in 1950.
Re-elected in 1952.
Re-elected in 1954.
Re-elected in 1956.
[data missing]
 
John V. Lindsay
(New York)
Republican January 3, 1959 –
December 31, 1965
86th
87th
88th
89th
Elected in 1958.
Re-elected in 1960.
Re-elected in 1962.
Re-elected in 1964.
Resigned after being elected as Mayor of New York City.
Vacant January 1, 1966 –
February 7, 1966
89th [data missing]
 
Theodore R. Kupferman
(New York)
Republican February 8, 1966 –
January 3, 1969
89th
90th
Elected to finish Lindsay's term.
Re-elected in 1966.
[data missing]
 
Ed Koch
(New York)
Democratic January 3, 1969 –
January 3, 1973
91st
92nd
Elected in 1968.
Re-elected in 1970.
Redistricted to 18th district
 
John M. Murphy
(Staten Island)
Democratic January 3, 1973 –
January 3, 1981
93rd
94th
95th
96th
Redistricted from 16th district and re-elected in 1972.
Re-elected in 1974.
Re-elected in 1976.
Re-elected in 1978.
[data missing]
 
Guy Molinari
(Staten Island)
Republican January 3, 1981 –
January 3, 1983
97th Elected in 1980.
Redistricted to 14th district
 
Ted Weiss
(New York)
Democratic January 3, 1983 –
September 14, 1992
98th
99th
100th
101st
102nd
Redistricted from 20th district and re-elected in 1982.
Re-elected in 1984.
Re-elected in 1986.
Re-elected in 1988.
Re-elected in 1990.
Died.
Vacant September 15, 1992 –
November 2, 1992
102nd [data missing]
 
Jerry Nadler
(New York)
Democratic November 3, 1992 –
January 3, 1993
Elected to finish Weiss's term.
Redistricted to the 8th district.
 
Eliot Engel
(The Bronx)
Democratic January 3, 1993 –
January 3, 2013
103rd
104th
105th
106th
107th
108th
109th
110th
111th
112th
Redistricted from the 19th district and re-elected in 1992.
Re-elected in 1994.
Re-elected in 1996.
Re-elected in 1998.
Re-elected in 2000.
Re-elected in 2002.
Re-elected in 2004.
Re-elected in 2006.
Re-elected in 2008.
Re-elected in 2010.
Redistricted to the 16th district.
2003–2013
Parts of the Bronx, Rockland, Westchester counties
 
 
Nita Lowey
(Harrison)
Democratic January 3, 2013 –
January 3, 2021
113th
114th
115th
116th
Redistricted from the 18th district and re-elected in 2012.
Re-elected in 2014.
Re-elected in 2016.
Re-elected in 2018.
Retired.
2013–2023
Rockland, parts of Westchester County
 
 
Mondaire Jones
(Nyack)
Democratic January 3, 2021 –
January 3, 2023
117th Elected in 2020.
Ran in the 10th district and lost renomination.
 
Mike Lawler
(Pearl River)
Republican January 3, 2023 –
present
118th Elected in 2022. 2023–2025
Rockland, parts of Dutchess, Putnam, Westchester counties
 

Election results edit

Note that in New York State electoral politics there are numerous minor parties at various points on the political spectrum. Certain parties will invariably endorse either the Republican or Democratic candidate for every office, hence the state electoral results contain both the party votes, and the final candidate votes (Listed as "Recap").

New York's 17th congressional district, 2022
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican Mike Lawler 125,738 44.05%
Conservative Mike Lawler 17,812 6.24%
Total Mike Lawler 143,550 50.29%
Democratic Sean Patrick Maloney 133,457 46.76%
Working Families Sean Patrick Maloney 8,273 2.90%
Total Sean Patrick Maloney (Incumbent) 141,730 49.65%
Write-in 150 0.05%
Total votes 285,430 100%
US House election, 2020: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes %
Democratic Mondaire Jones 183,975 55.3
Working Families Mondaire Jones 13,378 4.0
Total Mondaire Jones 197,353 59.3
Republican Maureen McArdle Schulman 117,307 35.3
Conservative Yehudis Gottesfeld 8,887 2.7
Independent Joshua Eisen 6,363 1.9
SAM Michael Parietti 2,745 0.8
Total votes 332,655 100.0
Democratic hold
US House election, 2018: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Nita Lowey (incumbent) 170,168 88 −20.6
Reform Joseph Ciardullo 23,150 12
Turnout 193,318 100 −9.8
US House election, 2016: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Nita Lowey (incumbent) 214,530 100 +118.5
Turnout 214,530 100 +18.1
US House election, 2014: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Nita Lowey (incumbent) 98,150 54 −42.7
Republican Chris Day 75,781 41.7 −17.5
N/A Blank/Void/Scattering 7,743 4.3
Turnout 181,674 100 −38.9
US House election, 2012: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Nita Lowey 171,417 57.6 +79.7
Republican Joe Carvin 91,899 30.9 +208.4
N/A Blank/Void/Scattering 31,292 10.5
Independent Francis Morganthaler 2,771 0.9
Turnout 297,379 100 +113.7
US House election, 2010: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Eliot L. Engel (incumbent) 95,346 68.5 −36.2
Republican Anthony Mele 29,792 21.4 −17.2
N/A Blank/Void/Scattering 8,327 6
Conservative York J. Kleinhandler 5,661 4.1
Turnout 139,126 100 −38.7
US House election, 2008: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Eliot L. Engel (incumbent) 149,676 65.9 +59.8
Republican Robert Goodman 35,994 15.8 +24.7
N/A Blank/Void/Scattering 41,464 18.3
Turnout 227,134 100 +85.4
US House election, 2006: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Eliot L. Engel (incumbent) 93,614 76.4 +0.2
Republican Jim Faulkner 28,842 23.6 +1.6
Majority 64,772 52.9 −1.3
Turnout 122,456 100 −33.6
US House election, 2004: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Eliot L. Engel (incumbent) 140,530 76.2 +13.6
Republican Matt I. Brennan 40,524 22.0 −12.4
Conservative Kevin Brawley 3,482 1.9 +1.9
Majority 100,006 54.2 +26.0
Turnout 184,536 100 +49.0
US House election, 2002: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Eliot L. Engel (incumbent) 77,535 62.6 −27.1
Republican C. Scott Vanderhoef 42,634 34.4 +24.1
Right to Life Arthur L. Gallagher 1,931 1.6 +1.6
Green Elizabeth Shanklin 1,743 1.4 +1.4
Majority 34,901 28.2 −51.2
Turnout 123,843 100 −3.5
US House election, 2000: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Eliot L. Engel (incumbent) 115,093 89.7 +1.7
Republican Patrick McManus 13,201 10.3 −1.7
Majority 101,892 79.4 +3.4
Turnout 128,294 100 +39.5
US House election, 1998: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Eliot L. Engel (incumbent) 80,947 88.0 +3.0
Republican Peter Fiumefreddo 11,037 12.0 −1.3
Majority 69,910 76.0 +4.4
Turnout 91,984 100 −22.8
US House election, 1996: New York District 17
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Democratic Eliot L. Engel (incumbent) 101,287 85.0
Republican Denis McCarthy 15,892 13.3
Independence Dennis Coleman 2,008 1.7
Majority 85,395 71.6
Turnout 119,187 100

See also edit

References edit

  1. ^ "My Congressional District".
  2. ^ "2022 Cook PVI: District Map and List". Cook Political Report. Retrieved January 10, 2023.
  3. ^ Bowman, Bridget (October 10, 2019). "Appropriations Chairwoman Nita Lowey announces retirement". Roll Call. Washington, DC. Retrieved October 10, 2019.
  4. ^ Rep. Maloney concedes to Lawler in District 17, retrieved November 9, 2022
  5. ^ "House Dem campaign chief Maloney concedes defeat in New York". POLITICO. Retrieved November 9, 2022.
  6. ^ Kornbluh, Jacob (August 16, 2022). "Sean Patrick Maloney locks in Jewish support in a competitive reelection bid for upstate New York seat". The Forward. Retrieved November 28, 2022.
  7. ^ @jacobkornbluh (November 2, 2022). "Register" (Tweet). Retrieved November 28, 2022 – via Twitter.
  • Martis, Kenneth C. (1989). The Historical Atlas of Political Parties in the United States Congress. New York: Macmillan Publishing Company.
  • Martis, Kenneth C. (1982). The Historical Atlas of United States Congressional Districts. New York: Macmillan Publishing Company.
  • Congressional Biographical Directory of the United States 1774–present
  • 2004 House election data Clerk of the House of Representatives
  • 2002 House election data "
  • 2000 House election data "
  • 1998 House election data "
  • 1996 House election data "