Summary
The Padaei (Greek: Παδαῖοι) or the Padaeans are an Indian tribe described by the Greek historian Herodotus in The Histories. Herodotus describes them (III.101) as being darker than other Indians and living in a place which is very distant from Persia towards the south and east. An extract from his work (III.99) includes the following:
- "Another tribe of Indians, called the Padaei, who live to the east of these marsh Indians, are nomadic and eat raw meat. They are said to have the following customs. If any of their compatriots -- a man or a woman -- is ill, his closest male friends (assuming that it is a man who is ill) kill him, on the grounds that if he wasted away in illness his flesh would become spoiled. He denies that he is ill, but they take no notice, kill him, and have a feast. Exactly the same procedure is followed by a woman's closest female friends when it is a woman who is ill. They sacrifice and eat anyone who reaches old age, but it is unusual for anyone to do so, because they kill everyone who falls ill before reaching old age."[1]
Scholars in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries suggested a number of possible identifications of the Padaei. Newbold thought that they were likely to be the Batta, a tribe of Sumatra, who he said continued to practice cannibalism.[2] Others have recorded that the Batta of the central Sumatran highlands not only were cannibals,[3] but they also formerly ate their elders.[4][5] Wheeler cited scholars who connected the name "Padaei" variously with a town in Little Tibet (Ladakh), a river in Kutch and the Ganges. He suggested that the name might be a general name or term for the nomadic inhabitants of north-western India.[6] William Smith, citing Mannert, suggested that they might be Tatars, and not an Indian tribe.[7]Latham pointed to the similarity of the name "Padaei" with that of the Batta and the Veddas, and concluded that all that could be said as to the Padaei's identity was that they were a "rude tribe in contact with an Indian population."[8] Rawlinson suggested that they may be the "Bhils, Gonds, or other aboriginal races of central India."[9]
The reliability of Herodotus' description of the Padaei's cannibalistic practices has also been questioned by other scholars. Wheeler took the view that whether they were really cannibals "may be doubted."[6]James Rennell said that Herodotus' description of the Padaei was an "odd mixture of truth and falsehood" which was probably a result of what he considered Herodotus' "very confined knowledge of India."[10] Murphy and Mallory suggest that Herodotus' description may result from a misinterpretation of the ritual of dismemberment known to have been practiced by Iron Age cultures who are believed to have spoken Iranian languages.[11]
Footnotes edit
- ^ Herodotus, The Histories translated by Robin Waterfield. Oxford University Press (1998) ISBN 0-19-282425-2
- ^ Newbold 1839, pp. 371–4
- ^ William Marsden, The history of Sumatra: containing an account of the government, laws, customs and manners of the native inhabitants, with a description of the natural productions, and a relation of the ancient political state of that island. 2nd ed., London: Printed for the author (1784), p. 299.
- ^ Sophia Raffles, Memoirs of the Life and Public Services of Sir Thomas Stamford Raffles, v. II. London, James Duncan (1835), p. 81.
- ^ "Battas", Encyclopædia Britannica 11th ed.
- ^ a b Wheeler 1854, p. 310
- ^ Smith 1857, p. 50
- ^ Latham 1859, pp. 305–6
- ^ Rawlinson 1926, p. 22
- ^ Rennell 1830, pp. 404, 407–8
- ^ Murphy & Mallory 2000, pp. 392–4
References edit
- Latham, R.G. (1859), Descriptive Ethnology, vol. II, London: John van Voorst
- Murphy, E.M.; Mallory, J.P. (2000), "Herodotus and the cannibals", Antiquity, 74 (2): 388–94, doi:10.1017/S0003598X00059470, S2CID 163941620
- Newbold, T. J. (1839), Political and statistical account of the British settlements in the Straits of Malacca, vol. 2, London: John Murray
- Rawlinson, H.G. (1916), Intercourse between India and the western world (2nd ed.), London: Cambridge University Press
- Rennell, James (1830), The Geographical System of Herodotus Examined and Explained by a Comparison with those of the Ancient Authors, and with Modern Geography, vol. I (2nd ed.), London: C. J. G. & F. Rivington
- Smith, William (1857), Dictionary of Greek and Roman geography, vol. 2, London: Walton and Maberly
- Wheeler, J. Talboys (1854), The geography of Herodotus, London: Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans