Tarski's theorem about choice

Summary

In mathematics, Tarski's theorem, proved by Alfred Tarski (1924), states that in ZF the theorem "For every infinite set , there is a bijective map between the sets and " implies the axiom of choice. The opposite direction was already known, thus the theorem and axiom of choice are equivalent.

Tarski told Jan Mycielski (2006) that when he tried to publish the theorem in Comptes Rendus de l'Académie des Sciences de Paris, Fréchet and Lebesgue refused to present it. Fréchet wrote that an implication between two well known propositions is not a new result. Lebesgue wrote that an implication between two false propositions is of no interest.

Proof edit

The goal is to prove that the axiom of choice is implied by the statement "for every infinite set    ". It is known that the well-ordering theorem is equivalent to the axiom of choice; thus it is enough to show that the statement implies that for every set   there exists a well-order.

Since the collection of all ordinals such that there exists a surjective function from   to the ordinal is a set, there exists an infinite ordinal,   such that there is no surjective function from   to   We assume without loss of generality that the sets   and   are disjoint. By the initial assumption,   thus there exists a bijection  

For every   it is impossible that   because otherwise we could define a surjective function from   to   Therefore, there exists at least one ordinal   such that   so the set   is not empty.

We can define a new function:   This function is well defined since   is a non-empty set of ordinals, and so has a minimum. For every   the sets   and   are disjoint. Therefore, we can define a well order on   for every   we define   since the image of   that is,   is a set of ordinals and therefore well ordered.

References edit

  • Rubin, Herman; Rubin, Jean E. (1985), Equivalents of the Axiom of Choice II, North Holland/Elsevier, ISBN 0-444-87708-8
  • Mycielski, Jan (2006), "A system of axioms of set theory for the rationalists" (PDF), Notices of the American Mathematical Society, 53 (2): 209
  • Tarski, A. (1924), "Sur quelques theorems qui equivalent a l'axiome du choix", Fundamenta Mathematicae, 5: 147–154, doi:10.4064/fm-5-1-147-154