The Allmusic review by Joslyn Layne awarded the album 5 stars stating "Zorn skeptics will find the superb and elegant music on The Circle Maker surprisingly stable and accessible... All of these musicians are accomplished in jazz and improvised music, and have performed extensively in world and/or classical settings as well. The Circle Maker is a very necessary recording for all appreciators of chamber jazz, new Jewish music, or any of these stellar musicians."^[2]

All compositions by John Zorn

• Disc One: Issachar

1. "Tahah" – 2:30
2. "Sippur" – 3:21
3. "Karet" – 1:21
4. "Hadasha" – 5:36
5. "Taharah" – 3:51
6. "Mispar" – 2:47
7. "Ratzah" – 4:36
8. "Zebdi" – 1:51
9. "Yatzar" – 8:14 - misspelled as "Yatzah" on album sleeve ^[3]
10. "Malkhut" – 1:57
11. "Hodaah" – 3:49
12. "Elilah" – 3:21
13. "Meholalot" – 4:54
14. "Kochot" – 4:58
15. "Lachish" – 1:30
16. "Shidim" – 4:32
17. "Aravot" – 2:58
18. "Moshav" – 5:06

• Disc Two: Zevulun

1. "Lilin" – 6:58
2. "Hazor" – 4:45
3. "Kisofim" – 7:23
4. "Khebar" – 4:54
5. "Laylah" – 2:57
6. "Teli" – 4:14
7. "Tevel" – 4:27
8. "Eitan" – 2:02
9. "Ner Tamid" – 2:38
10. "Idalah-Abal" – 7:41
11. "Gevurah" – 6:51

• Disc One: Issachar – Recorded December 6, 1997, at Avatar Studio, New York City
• Disc Two: Zevulun – Recorded December 7, 1997, at Avatar Studio, New York City

• Disc One: Issachar – All tracks performed by the Masada String Trio
• Mark Feldman – violin
• Erik Friedlander – cello
• Greg Cohen – bass
• Disc Two: Zevulun – All tracks performed by the Bar Kokhba Sextet
• Marc Ribot – guitar
• Cyro Baptista – percussion
• Joey Baron – drums
• Mark Feldman – violin
• Erik Friedlander – cello
• Greg Cohen – bass

Production edit

• Produced by John Zorn
• Kazunori Sugiyama: Associate Producer
• Jim Anderson: Sound Engineer