Theodore II Laskaris

Summary

Theodore II Doukas Laskaris
Θεόδωρος Β΄ Δούκας Λάσκαρις
Emperor and Autocrat of the Romans
Theodore II Laskaris miniature.jpg
15th-century portrait of Theodore II (from a 15th-century codex containing a copy of the Extracts of History by Joannes Zonaras)
Emperor of Nicaea
Claimant Byzantine Emperor
Reign1254–1258
PredecessorJohn III Doukas Vatatzes
SuccessorJohn IV Laskaris
Born1221/1222
Nicaea
(present-day Iznik, Turkey)
Died(1258-08-18)18 August 1258
Magnesia
(now in Turkey)
SpouseElena of Bulgaria
Issue
more...
Irene Doukaina Laskarina
Eudoxia Laskarina
John IV Laskaris
HouseLaskaris (matrilineal)
Vatatzes (patrilineal)
FatherJohn III Doukas Vatatzes
MotherIrene Lascarina

Theodore II Doukas Laskaris or Ducas Lascaris (Greek: Θεόδωρος Β΄ Δούκας Λάσκαρις, Theodōros II Doukas Laskaris; 1221/1222 – August 18, 1258) was Emperor of Nicaea from 1254 to 1258. He was the only child of Emperor John III Doukas Vatatzes and Empress Irene Lascarina. His mother was the eldest daughter of Theodore I Laskaris who had established the Empire of Nicaea as a successor state to the Byzantine Empire in Asia Minor, after the crusaders captured the Byzantine capital, Constantinople, during the Fourth Crusade in 1204. Theodore received an excellent education from two renowned scholars, Nicephorus Blemmydes and George Akropolites. He made friends with young intellectuals, especially with a page of low birth, George Mouzalon. Theodore began to write treatises on theological, historical and philosophical themes in his youth.

Emperor John III arranged for Theodore to marry Elena of Bulgaria in 1235, to forge an alliance with her father, Ivan Asen II, against the Latin Empire of Constantinople. According to Theodore himself, their marriage was happy, and they had five or six children. From 1241, Theodore acted as his father's lieutenant in Asia Minor during his frequent military campaigns in the Balkan Peninsula. From around 1242, he was his father's co-ruler around 1242, but was not crowned as co-emperor. During this period, his relationship with some prominent aristocrats, particularly Theodore Philes, Michael Palaiologos, grew tense.

Theodore succeeded his father on 4 November 1254. He dismissed many high officials and army commanders of aristocratic origin, replacing them with loyal friends, including those of low birth. He made a defensive alliance with Kaykaus II, the Seljuk Sultan of Rum, against the Mongol Empire. He repelled a Bulgarian invasion of Thrace and Macedonia and forced Michael II Komnenos Doukas, the ruler of Epirus, to cede Dyrrachium on the coast of the Adriatic Sea to Nicaea. He introduced a military reform, recruiting more soldiers from among the native peasantry of Asia Minor. Michael II of Epirus forged an alliance with Stefan Uroš I, King of Serbia, and Manfred of Sicily against Nicaea. Theodore's newly appointed generals could not resist their joint invasion in 1257. Theodore fell seriously ill and could rarely take part in state administration during the last months of his life. He appointed George Mouzalon regent for his underage son, John IV, before he died of either chronic epilepsy or cancer. In ten days, Mouzalon fell victim to an aristocratic plot, and Michael Palaiologos assumed the regency.

Early life

Childhood

Theodore was born to Emperor John III Doukas Vatatzes and Irene Lascarina in the imperial palace in Nicaea in late 1221 or early 1222.[1] Irene was the eldest daughter of Theodore I Laskaris, the founder of the Empire of Nicaea.[1] Nicaea was a successor state of the Byzantine Empire, established after the crusaders (or Latins) captured Constantinople during the Fourth Crusade in 1204.[2][3] Vatatzes was Irene's third husband. He was born into a Byzantine aristocratic family related to the imperial dynasties of Komnenos and Angelos. When he wed Irene, he served as the commander of the imperial guard. Although Irene's two brothers had died prematurely, Theodore I did not name Vatatzes as his official heir. He most likely expected that his third wife, the Latin Maria of Courtenay, would bear sons, but he did not father children with her.[4] Theodore I died in November 1221. Vatatzes had to defeat the late emperor's brothers, Alexios and Isaac Laskaris, to seize the throne. His victory over his wife's uncles and their Latin allies in the Battle of Poimanenon in the winter of 1223–1224 opened the way for the reconquest of Byzantine territories lost to the Latins in Asia Minor.[5]

Theodore was his parents' only child as his mother suffered a horse riding accident and could not bear children after his birth. He adopted his mother's family name.[6] He was "raised as usual for a royal child", according to his own words, most probably referring to his upbringing in the women's quarter of the palace and the luxury surrounding him. His childhood was joyful and he "often received greatest solace" from his father. He also remembered his parents did not punish him when his tutor had accused him of misdemeanors.[7]

Education

Ruins of stone walls.
Ruins of the walls of Nicaea.

If Theodore's formal education began at the age when most aristocratic children were taught to write and read, he was entrusted to an elementary teacher's care in 1228. As part of his education, he memorized texts from the Bible and prayed three times a day. He could quote from the Psalms and the parables of Jesus by heart until the end of his life.[8] Theodore's secondary education began around 1230. He detested his principal tutor (or baioulos) and described him as a "great babbler" in his works, without mentioning his name. He studied grammar (that is Attic Greek), poetry, rhetoric, logic, mathematics, astronomy, geometry and music for three years. His grammatical studies raised his lifelong interest in words with multiple meaning and in etymologies. The young Theodore was captivated by the orations of Demosthenes and Hermogenes of Tarsus. He also held theologian Gregory of Nazianzus in high esteem. His tutor mocked him for "philosophizing" and urged Theodore to spend more time with military and diplomatic studies. Theodore was a passionate hunter and polo player with remarkable riding skills.[9]

Negotiations over Theodore's marriage with Elena of Bulgaria began shortly after the Battle of Klokotnitsa. Her father, Emperor (or Tzar) Ivan Asen II of Bulgaria, inflicted a crushing defeat on the Emperor of Thessalonica and ruler of Epirus, Theodore Komnenos Doukas, early in 1230. The battle weakened Nicaea's rival for the revival of the Byzantine Empire, Epirus, and made Bulgaria the dominant power of the Balkan Peninsula.[10] The marriage of Theodore and Elena sealed their fathers' alliance against the Latin Empire of Constantinople in 1235. Bulgarian and Nicaean troops laid siege to Constantinople, but could not capture the city. Ivan Asen did a volte-face (about face), allying himself with the Latins to stop Nicaean expansion in Thrace in 1237, only to return to his alliance with Nicaea before the end of the year. His father-in-law's tactical moves convinced Theodore that he could not fully trust the Bulgarians—a view he held for the rest of his life.[11]

Theodore approached a most renowned teacher, Nicephorus Blemmydes, to take philosophy classes from him. Blemmydes was the hegumen (or head) of a monastery at Ephesus. Theodore attended his philosophy classes while he was staying in his father's winter palace at nearby Nymphaion. Blemmydes' zealous Aristotelianism had a strong impact on Theodore, who often mentioned Aristotelian notions, like potentiality and actuality, in his writings. Blemmydes was accused of embezzlement by one of his students early in the 1240s. Although Vatatzes' intervention saved him from imprisonment, he abandoned teaching. Theodore continued to visit Blemmydes regularly and maintained a correspondence with him. A young scholar, George Akropolites, replaced Blemmydes as Theodore's principal tutor. Born in Constantinople, Akropolites had firsthand experience with the Latin rule in the city. He completed Theodore's education in logic and mathematics.[3][12]

Theodore's mother died late in 1239.[13] Vatatzes re-married in late summer of 1240, taking an illegitimate daughter of Frederick II, Holy Roman Emperor, Constanza, whose name was changed to Anna. She was around ten and Vatatzes started a scandalous affair with one of her Italian ladies-in-waiting, named Marchesina. She was granted the right to wear purple shoes and to harness her horse with purple trappings, like the Emperor's closest relatives.[14]

Youth

First administrative tasks

Head of a bearded man wearing a crown.
John III Vatatzes.

If Theodore's father adopted his predecessors' practice, Theodore was still a child when he was made his father's co-ruler. Akropolites mentioned Theodore as a co-emperor when narrating events that occurred from 1235 to 1237 and in 1242. In his correspondence, Theodore referred to himself as "my imperial majesty" from around 1242. He was not crowned during his father's lifetime—a likely explanation for the denial of his co-emperorship by two later Byzantine historians, George Pachymeres and Nicephorus Gregoras.[15] Theodore's authority was considerable: he granted estates and salaries and intervened in legal disputes. On Blemmydes' petition, he ordered Nicephorus, the metropolitan bishop of Ephesus, to return an allegedly unlawfully purchased piece of land to Blemmydes' monastery. During his father's absence, he presided over sessions of the privy council and proposed candidates to vacant Church offices.[16]

John III Vatatzes again laid siege to Constantinople in May 1241, but he quickly realized he could not capture the city. He started peace negotiations, and Theodore accompanied his father to the meetings with the Latin envoys. They signed a two-year truce on 24 June. John II Asen died in the same month and his death weakened Bulgaria. Vatatzes launched a military campaign against the Bulgarians' Epirote allies late in 1241. Before departing for the military campaign, he appointed Theodore his lieutenant in Asia Minor. Theodore, like his father and grandfather, held an itinerant court and visited most Anatolian towns and villages.[17]

A Mongol general, Baiju, invaded the Seljuk Sultanate of Rum from the east and captured Erzurum. Theodore informed his father, who was besieging Thessalonica, but Vatatzes did not abandon the siege. His persistence was rewarded when the ruler of Thessalonica John Komnenos Doukas renounced the title of emperor in return for the Byzantine court title despot from Vatatzes. The Mongols launched a new military campaign against the Seljuks and routed Sultan Kaykhusraw II at the Battle of Köse Dağ on 26 June 1243. After the Seljuks agreed to pay a yearly tribute to the Mongols, Nicaea remained the only Anatolian state that preserved full independence. The fear of a Mongol invasion became a constant element of Nicaean diplomacy.[18][19]

Vatatzes again charged Theodore with the administration of Asia Minor when he launched a new military campaign in Thrace in 1246. After Vatatzes captured Serres, the leading citizens of Thessalonica did not risk a prolonged siege. They opened the gates of their city and paid voluntary homage to Vatatzes. As most Macedonian towns followed their example, Vatatzes almost doubled his empire's territory.[20][21]

Friends

Theodore forged a bond of close friendship with a circle of young intellectuals. All born after the Latin conquest of Constantinople, they did not experience the shock of exile, unlike many of their fathers' "humiliated generation" (as Patriarch Germanus II of Constantinople referred to them). His friends' companionship helped Theodore come through his periods of melancholy, likely caused by anxiety over his public duties. His closest friend, George Mouzalon, was a page in his retinue during their childhood. The three Mouzalon brothers—George, Theodore and Andronikos—were, in Blemmydes's words, "of despicably low birth", but they were talented singers and musicians. Most of Theodor's other confidants, like Joseph Mesopotamites and Konstas Hagiotheodorites, were related to high-ranking officials and churchmen.[22]

Theodore often made fun of bishops for their self-aggrandizement, their barbaric speech or ignorantly heretical statements, or even for their physical appearance. Theodore was also the subject of mockery: his fellow students teased him for his style of argument during philosophical discussions. Critical remarks made by bishops and aristocrats were more dangerous. Metropolitan Nicephorus of Ephesus rebuked Theodore for his pride and for his non-observance of the rules of fasting. A military commander, Kalothetos, made disrespectful remarks about Theodore. The relationship between Theodore and the governor at Thessalonica, Theodore Philes, was extremely tense. Philes circulated defamatory poems about Theodore's alleged affair with an unnamed woman, while Theodore blamed Philes for the murder of Theodore's friend, Tribides. Tribides' fate shows that Theodore could send his confidants to the newly conquered European territories during his father's reign. Philes' accusations reached the ears of Blemmydes who did not tolerate sexual misconduct. Around 1248, Blemmydes had denied Marchesina and her retinue entry to his monastery at Ephesus. Now, he addressed a mirror for princes (instruction), entitled Imperial Statue, to Theodore and his father, warning them against lechery and squandering public funds. Theodore could not convince him of his innocence.[23]

Towards sole rule

Vatatzes was making preparations for a new attack on Constantinople, but the ruler of Epirus, Michael II Komnenos Doukas, invaded Nicaean territory in Macedonia in the spring of 1252. Vatatzes appointed Theodore his viceroy in Asia Minor and launched a counter-attack against Michael II, forcing him to return to Epirus. Elena of Bulgaria died unexpectedly before the end of August. Theodore mourned his wife for more than the customary forty days. He abandoned fasting and wearing black only on his father's command. His wife's death intensified Theodore's melancholy. He secluded himself in the palace and dedicated his time to philosophical studies and writing. He only resumed his regular visits to the towns of Asia Minor in 1253.[24][25]

Emperor Frederick II's son and successor, Conrad, forced most relatives of his father's mistress, Bianca Lancia, into exile early in 1253. They fled to Nicaea and sought asylum from Bianca's daughter, Empress Constanza-Anna, early in 1253. Theodore received the exiles, because his father was staying in Thrace. Conrad changed his mind and sent the erudite Berthold of Hohenburg, an in-law of the Lancias, to Nicaea to begin negotiations with them. While waiting for his father's return from Thrace, Theodore had philosophical conversations with Hohenburg. The study of ancient Greek philosophers had intensified in Europe, and Hohenburg asked Theodore for Greek philosophical works. This request reinforced Theodore's pride in the Greeks' ancient heritage, and he decided to publish his works.[26]

Vatatzes returned to Nicaea in the winter of 1253. Early in 1254, he fell ill suddenly and never fully recovered. His illness made Theodore the actual ruler of the empire, but the change in his position did not prevent him from making arrangements for the publications of his works. His father was still alive when news of the Mongols' preparations for a new invasion of Asia Minor reached Nicaea.[27]

Reign

Ascension

John III Vatatzes died in Nicaea on 4 November 1254, leaving a flourishing empire to Theodore.[3] Theodore was acclaimed emperor, but he was not crowned because the patriarchal throne was vacant. In his funerary speech at Vatatzes' burial, Acropolites expressed his hope that Theodore would lead the Nicaeans to expel the Latins from Constantinople, comparing him with the "pillar of fire" of the Book of Exodus, guiding the Israelites.[28] Theodore could actually not risk launching an attack against Constantinople, because his empire was surrounded by hostile powers.[29]

Theodore forbade his father's widow, Anna-Constanza, from returning to her Sicilian homeland. This act outraged her brother, Manfred, who had recently become the actual ruler of the Kingdom of Sicily.[30] Theodore had a meeting with the Seljuk Sultan of Rum, Kaykaus II, in Philadelphia. They concluded a defensive alliance against the Mongols. Kaykaus had acknowledged the Mongols' suzerainty, but had not visited the court of Great Khan Möngke to pay homage to him.[31][32]

Theodore wanted to make Blemmydes the new patriarch, but his old tutor refused. His next candidate, a hermit with an aristocratic background, Arsenios Autoreianos, accepted the offer. The new Patriarch crowned and anointed Theodore emperor—according to scholarly consensus, on Christmas 1254. Arsenios' allegedly irregular appointment would give rise to the conflict known as "Arsenite Schism", lasting from 1265 to 1310.[33] Arsenios was always Theodore's loyal supporter and obeyed his commands.[34]

Theodore did not trust the aristocrats and wrote of "illicit love affairs and very unjust plots", without naming his opponents, in a letter addressed to George Mouzalon in December 1254. Historian Michael Angold proposes that Emperor Frederick II's similar policy may have inspired Theodore's "more autocratic stance towards his aristocracy".[35] Theodore appointed George Mouzalon to be the commander-in-chief of the mobile army as the new megas domestikos. George's brother, Andronikos, was designated as the new protovestiarites (or commander of the guards of the imperial palace). Theodore also demonstrated his favor towards a general of common origin, Constantine Margarites. He also tried to compensate the aristocrats who had been put aside during this father's reign. He recalled his mother's uncles, Michael and Manuel Laskaris, from their exiles and made two members of the rebellious Nestongos family, George and Isaac, generals. His appointments offended most aristocrats.[36]

Wars with Bulgaria

A young bearded man wearing a crown.
Theodore wearing imperial insignia.

The young Bulgarian Tzar, Michael II Asen, exploited Vatatzes' death to reconquer the lands he had seized from Bulgaria after 1241. Michael invaded Macedonia and Thrace in December 1254 or January 1255.[6][30][37] Most Nicaean garrisons at the fortresses were small, and the local Bulgarians supported the invaders.[37][38] The Bulgarians quickly seized most Thracian fortresses. Two Macedonian towns, Veles and Skopje, also surrendered to them. A hastily summoned council of war accepted George Mouzalon's proposal of an immediate counter-attack. Theodore decided to lead the campaign himself and entrusted Mouzalon with the administration of Asia Minor in February 1255. His surprise attack forced the invaders to withdraw from Thrace, and he ordered two aristocrats, Alexios Strategopoulos and Demetrios Torinikes, to chase the Bulgarians. The two generals led their troops across the passes of the Rhodope Mountains in constant fear of an ambush. When they unexpectedly heard the sounds of the horns of shepherds and swineherds, they broke into a run in panic, abandoning their baggage. The fiasco outraged Theodore, and he ordered them to hurry to his camp at Adrianople, but both commanders disobeyed.[39][40]

A Bulgarian renegate (traitor) in Nicaean service, Dragotas, switched sides and laid siege to Melnik in the summer. Theodore hastily departed from Adrianople to lead relief forces to the town. The Bulgarians lay an ambush for him along the Rupel Pass, but he avoided it and Dragotas abandoned the siege on Theodore's arrival. From Melnik, Theodore went to Thessalonica and dismissed his old opponent, Philes. He closed down the local mint, because he wanted to establish a centralized system of financial administration in Asia Minor, with a new treasury at Astritzion on the Asian coast of the Hellespont. Theodore invaded Macedonia and forced the Bulgarian garrison in Veles to surrender, but drought prevented him from continuing the military campaign across the arid Ovče Pole. He went to Serres where he confirmed the fiscal privileges of Macedonian towns. He also ordered the arrest of Constantine Kabasila, Archbishop of Ohrid, assuming that Kabasila was Michael II of Epirus' loyal supporter.[41]

A report about a Mongol invasion of Asia Minor forced Theodore to leave Macedonia in late autumn of 1255. After the report had proved false, he launched an attack against the fortress of Tzepaina. He had to abandon the campaign, because his army could not pass across the narrow and frosty mountain passes. He returned to Anatolia around the end of the year. He showered his confidants with honors and gifts. He made Manuel Laskaris and Constantine Margarites the commanders-in-chief of his troops in Thrace and charged George Mouzalon with implementing military reforms. He also ordered the punishment of members of old aristocratic families. Constantine Strategopoulos and Theodore Philes were blinded; Alexios Strategopoulos and Alexios Raoul's four sons were imprisoned. Theodore's cousin, Michael Palaiologos, fled to the Seljuks to escape imprisonment. Theodore took advantage of the emperors' right to control aristocratic marriages to establish family ties between his lowborn favorites and the old aristocracy. George Mouzalon married Palaiologos' niece, Theodora Kantakouzene Palaiologina, Andronikos Mouzalon wed a daughter of Alexios Raoul.[42]

Theodore decided to resume negotiations about the church union with Pope Alexander IV and sent envoys to Rome in April or May 1256. Divergent views on the procession of the Holy Spirit had always been an important cause of the schism between the Orthodox and Catholic Churches. Orthodox theologians maintained that the Holy Spirit proceeded from the Father alone, while Catholic theologians stated that the Holy Spirit proceeded from the Father "and the Son". Theodore commissioned Blemmydes to summarize the Orthodox position. Blemmydes adopted a conciliatory approach, concluding that a statement about the procession of the Holy Spirit from the Father through the Son was fully in conformity with the Bible and the Church Fathers' works. Theodore did not accept his tutor's view and insisted on the traditional Orthodox doctrine.[43]

Michael II of Bulgaria dispatched Cuman raiders to plunder Thrace early in 1256. Although Theodore had instructed Laskaris and Margarites to adopt a defensive strategy, they chased the Cumans, but the invaders inflicted a heavy defeat on their troops. Theodore assembled a new army, partially mustered among the Anatolian peasantry, and crossed the Hellespont. He sent troops, including Cuman horsemen in his service, against the invaders and they routed the enemy forces in two battles in Thrace.[44] He entered into peace negotiations with Michael II with the mediation of Rostislav Mikhailovich, Duke of Macsó. Michael II had recently married Rostislav's daughter and Rostislav's wife, Anna of Hungary, was Theodore's cousin. Rostislav came to Thrace to reach an agreement with Theodore. Akropolites drafted a treaty about the restoration of the prewar boundaries between Nicaea and Bulgaria. Rostislav accepted it and signed the peace treaty on Michael II's behalf on 29 June. The treaty prescribed that Michael II cede Tzepaina to the Nicaeans, but the Bulgarian garrison was not withdrawn immediately from the fortress. Theodore became convinced that Rostislav had deceived him and ordered the public whipping of Akropolites. His act proved imprudent, because the Bulgarians ceded the fortress in early September. Theodore sent George Mouzalon to Akropolites to seek a reconciliation.[37][45][46]

The peace treaty aroused much indignation in Bulgaria, enabling Michael II's cousin, Kaliman, to stage a plot and dethrone the Tsar. Kaliman seized the throne, but he never gained the support of the army. After he fell victim to a new plot, Rostislav Mikhailovich and Michael II's brother-in-law, Mitso, laid claim to the throne. Most boyars (or noblemen) preferred a third candidate, one of their number, Konstantin Tih, although he was not related to the Asen dynasty.[47][48][49]

Expansion

Theodore's war against Bulgaria brought about a rapprochement between Epirus and Serbia. Michael II of Epirus made a formal alliance with Stefan Uroš I, King of Serbia. He also sent gifts to the Albanian chiefs who had acknowledged Nicaean suzerainty to gain their support. Theodore's daughter, Maria, and Michael II's son and heir, Nikephoros, had been engaged during Vatatzes' reign. After making peace with the Bulgarians, Theodore ordered Michael II to send Nikephoros to Thessalonica to wed Maria. Nikephoros was accompanied by his mother, Theodora Petraliphaina. Theodore took her into custody, only allowing her to return to Epirus after Michael II ceded Servia and Dyrrachium to him. The possession of the two towns secured the Nicaean control of the Via Egnatia, but Michael II remained hostile to Theodore.[6][50]

Theodore received the papal legate, Bishop Constantine of Orvieto, in Thessalonica. Their negotiations proved fruitless, because the legate's authorization was limited and Theodore was unwilling to make concessions for the church union. He also preserved the right to convoke the Orthodox bishops to a church union to discuss the conditions of the union. Theodore maintained a correspondence with the Holy See, but he did not initiate new negotiations with the Holy See.[51]

The Mongols invaded Asia Minor and defeated Kaykaus II on 14 October 1256. Theodore hurried back to Anatolia to oversee the preparations for the defense. Kaykaus sought asylum in Nicaea and the Mongols installed his brother, Kilij Arslan IV, as the new sultan of Rum. Theodore assembled his troops on the plains near Magnesia. The Mongol ruler of Persia, the Ilkhan Hülagü sent a delegation to Theodore to begin negotiations about Kaykaus' future. Hülegü agreed to withdraw his army from Rum and ordered the division of the sultanate between Kaykaus and Kilij Arslan in the spring of 1257. Before leaving for Rum, Kaykaus ceded four fortresses in the valley of the river Lycus to Nicaea in return for a contingent of 300 auxiliary troops.[52][53] His achievements made Theodore self-confident. He proudly stated that his empire included territories as far as Dyrrachium on the Adriatic Sea and Cape Karambis on the Black Sea. His success during the war against Bulgaria had convinced him he should recruit soldiers from among Anatolian peasants. In a letter to Blemmydes, he stated the "Hellenes" were more reliable than foreign mercenaries.[54][55]

Illness and death

Map showing the Byzantine Empire and its neighbors.
The restored Byzantine Empire at the beginning of Michael VIII Palaiologos' rule (1263)—most European territories were seized by Theodore's father between 1246 and 1254

Theodore fell seriously ill in November 1257. George Pachymeres, who was less than sixteen years old at the time, diagnosed his illness as epilepsy, mentioning that Theodore had often lost consciousness and "collapsed to the ground". Pachymeres also described Theodore's unusual appointments and his attempts to forge marriage alliances between aristocrats and commoners as symptoms of his disease. Akropolites only noticed extreme weight loss, reducing Theodore's entire body to a skeleton, while Blemmydes described Theodore's illness as "a scourge and a strange disease", also mentioning Theodore's melancholy and phobias. Theodore himself wrote of insufferable aching and paralysis in the arms. Modern historians of diseases have not agreed on a diagnosis of Theodore's illness. John Lascaratos and Panaghiotis V. Zis maintain that Pachymeres' prognosis was correct, concluding that Theodore developed epilepsy of the tonic-clonic type in his late twenties.[56] Historian Donald M. Nicol proposes that Theodore's illness "made him the prey of his moods, and he compensated for his nervousness by an autocratic and obstinate temper".[34] Medical historian Georgios Makris, however, concludes in his 1995 study on epilepsy in the Byzantine Empire that Theodore did not suffer from epilepsy. Historian Dimiter Angelov, who does not accept Pachymeres' diagnosis, proposes that Theodore most likely had cancer of the brain, the spine or the lungs.[57]

His illness prevented Theodore from commanding his troops in person. The commanders of the army in Macedonia, most of them of humble origin, recently appointed by Theodore, could not prevent the Epirotes, Albanians and Serbians from raiding Nicaean territories. Stefan Uroš I defeated the Nicaean troops near Prilep. Michael II's sister-in-law, Maria Petraliphina, entered into a correspondence with Theodore's commander, Constantine Chabaron, making him believe that she was eager to marry him, but Chabaron was captured during their meeting. Theodore's newly assembled army of Anatolian peasants was routed at Edessa. Michael Palaiologos, who had been allowed to return from his exile, lead a new army to Macedonia. He defeated the Epirotes, but Theodore ordered him to return instead of marching to Prilep. Palaiologos' withdrawal enabled Michael II to seize Prilep and capture Akropolites. Michael II was planning to launch an attack against Thessalonica, but Manfred of Sicily renewed his predecessors' claim to Byzantine territories and invaded Epirus from the west. Michael II, who did not want to abandon his plan, concluded an alliance with Manfred who expelled the Nicaean garrisons from Dyrrachium and other fortresses on the Adriatic by the end of February 1258.[30][58][59]

Konstantin Tich of Bulgaria repudiated his first wife and sued for the hand of Theodore's eldest daughter, Irene. He knew that his marriage to Irene, who was Tzar Ivan Asen II's granddaughter, could strengthen his claim to rule. Theodore wanted to confirm his peace treaty with Bulgaria and accepted Konstantin Tich's offer. Irene went to Bulgaria to marry Konstantin Tich.[60][61]

Theodore rarely left his palace at Magnesia during the last months of his life. He was convinced that sorcery caused his illness and accused his courtiers of casting spells on him, sending many of them for trial. Michael Palaiologos's sister, Maria-Martha, was the most famous victim of Theodore's paranoia. Theodore had forced her daughter, Theodora, to marry the elderly Basil Kaballarios, but the marriage was never consummated. After Kaballarios had attributed his impotence to his mother-in-law's spells, Theodore had her put into a sack filled with cats that tore her flesh. She was only released because Theodore suddenly panicked, fearing her spells. Also fearing her brother's revenge, Theodore had Michael Palaiologos imprisoned on charges of poisoning but soon set him free.[45] Theodore named his seven-year-old son, John, as his sole heir, appointing George Mouzalon regent until John came of age. He became a monk, but he kept his baptismal name. He summarized his sins in a treatise and asked the patriarchal synod to grant him absolution. He died in the imperial palace at Magnesia on 16 August 1258. He was buried next to his father in the Sosandra monastery on Mount Sipylus. His grave and the monastery were destroyed after the Turkish conquest of the region in the 13th century.[62]

The aristocrats had taken an oath of loyalty to Mouzalon at Theodore's deathbed, but they soon began conspiring against him. In ten days, Mouzalon was murdered, and Michael Palaiologos assumed the regency for the child-emperor, John IV Laskaris. Palaiologos convinced the aristocrats that an empire ruled by a boy could not resist enemy attacks, and he was proclaimed co-emperor as Michael VIII before the end of the year. When Michael VIII and John IV were crowned together early in 1259, the Patriarch put the crown first on Michael VIII's head. After concluding an agreement with Genoa against the Latin Empire, he dispatched Alexios Strategopoulos to spy on the defences of Constantinople. Taking advantage of the absence of the bulk of the Latin army, Strategopoulos seized Constantinople by a surprise attack on 25 July 1261. Michael VIII was crowned for the second time alone in the Hagia Sophia.[59][47][63] The child John IV was blinded on 25 December 1261, which prevented him from ruling.[64] His three unmarried sisters were married off to Italian and Bulgarian noblemen, because Michael VIII wanted to demonstrate that the Laskaris had lost their imperial status.[65]

Scholarship

A man of letters devoted to philosophical and theological studies, Theodore transformed his court into a center for renowned scholars shortly after his ascension to the throne.[3] He ordered that books that he and his father had collected in urban libraries be available to all who wanted to read them.[34][66] He began to write treatises on philosophical, theological and historical subjects already during his father's lifetime, but he decided to prepare manuscript editions of his works only after his meeting with Berthold of Hohenburg in 1353. His works were collected in four codices, but only three survived.[67]

Theodore's Satire of the Tutor, written most likely in 1240, is his earliest extant work. The satire is dedicated to his principal tutor, portraying him as an under-educated and rude man, who learned magic while staying in Bulgaria. He also wrote encomia in praise of the citizens of Nicaea, his father and Akropolites. Theodore's theological works—including his First Oration against the Latins, or, on the Procession of the Holy Spirit, and his treatise On the Trinity—demonstrate his adherence to Orthodox theology.[68] Theodore's Great Supplicatory Canon to Our Lady, a hymn to the Virgin Mary, is his best known work. He composed it just months before his death and it is still sung in Orthodox ceremonies.[69]

Family

Neither Theodore nor Elena reached the minimum legal age of marriage—fourteen for boys and twelve for girls—when they were married, but such an early marriage was not unique among Nicaean aristocrats and commoners. She was born to Ivan Asen II and Maria of Hungary in 1224. The wedding took place at Lampsakos in early 1235. Two years later, before launching an invasion of Nicaean territories in Thrace, her father forced Elena to return to Bulgaria, but peace was restored between the two empires and Elena returned to Theodore before the end of the year. Years later, Theodore described Elena as the flower of his youth and stated that their "bond of incomparable love" made them "happier than all people". Her sudden death in the spring or summer of 1252 plunged Theodore into grief. She gave birth to four or five daughters, and one son.[70] Their children were:

  • Irene who married Constantine Tikh of Bulgaria was Emperor Michael VIII's implacable enemy until her death around 1270.[71]
  • Maria who married Nikephoros I of Epirus deceased between early in 1257 and 1265.[72][73]
  • Theodora was married off by Michael VIII to a Morean nobleman, Maïos Débélikourtos, according to Pachymeres and Nicephorus Gregoras. Historian Albert Failler identifies him as Matthew of Mons who held the Barony of Veligosti in the Principality of Achaea.[74]
  • Eudoxia first married Count William-Peter of Ventimiglia who died around 1280. Her second husband, Roger Arnau, Count of Pallars, died in 1288. The widowed Euroxia had a love affair with the Aragonese admiral Bernat de Serria. She died in 1309.[75]
  • A Bulgarian boyar, Despot Jacob Svetoslav, married Theodore's unnamed daughter, according to Pachymeres. She may have been Theodore's illegitimate daughter, because other Byzantine historians failed to mention her.[76]
  • Theodore's only son, John, survived his mutilation, but he spent the rest of his life in prison. He died around 1309.[77]

See also

References

  1. ^ a b Angelov 2019, p. 57.
  2. ^ Nicol 1993, pp. 10–11.
  3. ^ a b c d Lascaratos & Zis 1998, p. 296.
  4. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 32–34.
  5. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 57–59.
  6. ^ a b c Treadgold 1997, p. 721.
  7. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 59–60, 257 (notes 21–22).
  8. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 64–66.
  9. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 68–72, 75–77.
  10. ^ Angold 2017, p. 738.
  11. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 65, 73–75.
  12. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 79, 85, 117–118.
  13. ^ Angelov 2019, p. 88.
  14. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 90–91.
  15. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 61, 258 (notes 34 and 36).
  16. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 98–101.
  17. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 92, 100.
  18. ^ Korobeinikov 2017, pp. 720–721.
  19. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 92–96.
  20. ^ Fine 2009, pp. 156–157.
  21. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 92, 96–97.
  22. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 109–118.
  23. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 90, 118–125.
  24. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 92, 128–132.
  25. ^ Fine 2009, p. 158.
  26. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 140–145.
  27. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 147–148.
  28. ^ Angelov 2019, p. 148.
  29. ^ Treadgold 1997, p. 730.
  30. ^ a b c Nicol 1993, p. 28.
  31. ^ Korobeinikov 2017, p. 721.
  32. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 149–150.
  33. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 150, 296 (note 25).
  34. ^ a b c Nicol 1993, p. 27.
  35. ^ Angold 2017, p. 748.
  36. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 151–152.
  37. ^ a b c Fine 2009, p. 159.
  38. ^ Kanellopoulos & Lekea 2007, p. 56.
  39. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 151–154.
  40. ^ Kanellopoulos & Lekea 2007, pp. 57–58.
  41. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 156–159.
  42. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 159–162, 169.
  43. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 162–163.
  44. ^ Kanellopoulos & Lekea 2007, pp. 59–60.
  45. ^ a b Lascaratos & Zis 1998, p. 297.
  46. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 164–166.
  47. ^ a b Treadgold 1997, p. 722.
  48. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 166–167.
  49. ^ Fine 2009, pp. 170–172.
  50. ^ Fine 2009, p. 160.
  51. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 168–169.
  52. ^ Korobeinikov 2017, pp. 721–722.
  53. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 169–171.
  54. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 172–174.
  55. ^ Kanellopoulos & Lekea 2007, p. 68.
  56. ^ Lascaratos & Zis 1998, pp. 297–298.
  57. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 381–383.
  58. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 175–176.
  59. ^ a b Fine 2009, p. 161.
  60. ^ Angelov 2019, p. 67.
  61. ^ Fine 2009, p. 172.
  62. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 178–180.
  63. ^ Nicol 1993, pp. 29–36.
  64. ^ Failler 1980, p. 65.
  65. ^ Nicol 1993, pp. 44–45.
  66. ^ Angelov 2019, p. 106.
  67. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 145, 323-326, 329.
  68. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 70-71,329-342.
  69. ^ Kanellopoulos & Lekea 2007, p. 62.
  70. ^ Angelov 2019, pp. 72–75.
  71. ^ Failler 1980, p. 67.
  72. ^ Failler 1980, p. 68.
  73. ^ Fine 2009, p. 169.
  74. ^ Failler 1980, pp. 68–70.
  75. ^ Failler 1980, pp. 70–72.
  76. ^ Failler 1980, pp. 72–73.
  77. ^ Failler 1980, pp. 76–77.

Sources

  • Angelov, Dimiter (2019). The Byzantine Hellene: The Life of Emperor Thodore Laskaris and Byzantium in the Thirteenth Century. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-108-48071-0.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
  • Angold, Michael (2017) [2008]. "After the Fourth Crusade: the Greek rump states and the recovery of Byzantium". In Shepard, Jonathan (ed.). The Cambridge History of the Byzantine Empire, c. 500–1492. Cambridge University Press. pp. 731–758. ISBN 978-0-521-83231-1.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
  • Failler, Albert (1980). "Chronologie et composition dans l'Histoire de Georges Pachymère [Chronology and composition in George Pachymeres' History]". Revue des études byzantine (in French). 38: 5–103. ISSN 0771-3347.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
  • Fine, John V. A (2009) [1994]. The Late Medieval Balkans: A Critical Survey from the Late Twelfth Century to the Ottoman Conquest. The University of Michigan Press. ISBN 978-0-472-08260-5.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
  • Kanellopoulos, Nicholas S.; Lekea, Joanne K. (2007). "The Struggle Between the Nicean Empire and the Bulgarian State (1254–1256): Towards a Revival of Byzantine Military Tactics under Theodore II Lascaris". In Rogers, Clifford J.; DeVries, Kelly; France, John (eds.). The Journal of Medieval Military History. V. The Boydell Press. pp. 56–69. ISBN 978-1-84383-339-0.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
  • Korobeinikov, D. A. (2017) [2008]. "Raiders and neighbours: the Turks (1040–1304)". In Shepard, Jonathan (ed.). The Cambridge History of the Byzantine Empire, c. 500–1492. Cambridge University Press. pp. 692–727. ISBN 978-0-521-83231-1.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
  • Lascaratos, John; Zis, Panaghiotis Vassilios (1998). "The epilepsy of the Emperor Theodore II Lascaris (1254–1258)". Journal of Epilepsy. 11 (6): 296–300. doi:10.1016/S0896-6974(98)00032-2. ISSN 0896-6974.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
  • Nicol, Donald M. (1993) [1972]. The Last Centuries of Byzantium, 1261–1453. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-43991-4.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
  • Treadgold, Warren (1997). A History of the Byzantine State and Society. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press. ISBN 0-8047-2630-2.

Further reading

Theodore II Laskaris
Laskarid dynasty
Born: unknown 1221 Died: 18 August 1258
Regnal titles
Preceded by
John III Doukas Vatatzes
Emperor of Nicaea
1254–1258
Succeeded by
John IV Doukas Laskaris