Tillie's Punctured Romance (1914 film)


Tillie's Punctured Romance is a 1914 American silent comedy film directed by Mack Sennett and starring Marie Dressler, Mabel Normand, Charlie Chaplin, and the Keystone Kops. The picture was the only feature-length comedy made by the Keystone Film Company.

Tillie's Punctured Romance
Directed byMack Sennett
Written byHampton Del Ruth
Craig Hutchinson
Mack Sennett
Based onTillie's Nightmare
by A. Baldwin Sloane and Edgar Smith
Produced byMack Sennett
StarringMarie Dressler
Mabel Normand
Charles Chaplin
Mack Swain
Charles Bennett
Chester Conklin
The Keystone Cops
Charley Chase (uncredited)
CinematographyHans F. Koenekamp (uncredited)
Frank D. Williams (uncredited)
Distributed byAlco Film Corporation[1]
Release date
  • December 21, 1914 (1914-12-21) (United States)
Running time
74 minutes
82 minutes (2003 restoration)
CountryUnited States
English intertitles

At the time of production Marie Dressler was a major stage star, and in this film Chaplin and Normand support her as leads within Keystone's stock company of actors.

The film is based on Dressler's stage play Tillie's Nightmare by A. Baldwin Sloane and Edgar Smith. Tillie's Punctured Romance is notable for being the last Chaplin film which he neither wrote nor directed, as well as the first feature-length slapstick comedy in all of cinema. In it, Chaplin plays a slightly different role from his Tramp character, which was relatively new at the time. However, he retains a moustache (here a, pencil-thin "dude" type rather than his usual "toothbrush"), thin cane and distinctive walk.

Given the combination of factors it seems likely that it is also the first feature to contain a "film within the film" where the couple go to the cinema to watch "A Thief's Fate" large sections of which are seen. Whilst this occupies less than one reel of the total six reels it is still significant.[2]


Tillie's Punctured Romance

Charles Chaplin portrays a womanizing city man who meets Tillie (Marie Dressler) in the country after a fight with his girlfriend (Mabel Normand). When he sees that Tillie's father (Mack Swain) has a very large bankroll for his workers, he persuades her to elope with him. In the city, he meets the woman he was seeing already, and tries to work around the complication to steal Tillie's money. He gets Tillie drunk in a restaurant and asks her to let him hold the pocketbook. Since she is drunk, she agrees, and he escapes with his old girlfriend and the money.

Later that day, they see a Keystone film in a nickelodeon entitled "A Thief's Fate" (which is, ironically, a melodrama, a type of film Keystone did not produce) which illustrates their thievery in the form of a morality play. They both feel guilty and leave the theater. While sitting on a park bench, a paperboy (Gordon Griffith) asks him to buy a newspaper. He does so, and reads the story about Tillie's Uncle Banks (Charles Bennett), a millionaire who died while on a mountain-climbing expedition. Tillie is named sole heir and inherits three million dollars. The man leaves his girlfriend on the park bench and runs to the restaurant, where Tillie is now forced to work to support herself as she is too embarrassed to go home. He begs her to take him back and although she is skeptical at first, she believes that he truly loves her and they marry. They move into the uncle's mansion and throw a big party, which ends horribly when Tillie finds her husband with his old girlfriend, smuggled into the house and working as one of their maids.

The uncle is found on a mountaintop, alive after all. He goes back to his mansion, in disarray after Tillie instigated a gunfight (a direct result of the husband smuggling the old girlfriend into the house) which, luckily, did not harm anyone. Uncle Banks insists that Tillie be arrested for the damage she has caused to his house. The three run from the cops all the way to a dock, where a car "bumps" Tillie into the water. She flails about, hoping to be rescued. She is eventually pulled to safety, and both Tillie and the man's girlfriend realize that they are too good for him. He leaves, and the two girls become friends.



Description of Marie Dressler's character
Description of Charlie Chaplin's character
Re-release poster with different billing and picture featuring Chaplin's Tramp, who does not appear in the film
Scene with Normand, Chaplin and Dressler
Uncredited[citation needed]


Mack Sennett, whilst working with a degree of autonomy, was working for the larger company of Kessel and Baumann.[5]

When slapstick impresario Mack Sennett proposed to adapt the 1910 Broadway comedy Tillie's Nightmare to the screen in 1914, he enlisted the immensely successful star of the stage production, the then 45-year-old Marie Dressler, to play the guileless ingenue, Tillie Banks.[6] Dressler was paid a huge fee of £2500 per week and was also meant to have a share of the profits of Kessler and Baumann but they passed the distribution contract to Alco, voiding Dressler's contract with K & B and forcing Dressler to sue them. The situation was further complicated by Alco going bust, mainly due to overpaying for the distribution rights: £100,000. Chaplin's salary was far less than Dressler, certainly under $1000 a week, as he demanded an increase to $1000 a week early in 1915.[7]

Comedian Charles Chaplin, who had been with Sennett's studio since December 1913, was selected to play opposite Dressler as Charlie, an unscrupulous playboy and bounder. Though Chaplin's signature "The Tramp" character was already well-developed in other Sennett one- and two-reel films (he had already appeared in more than 30 shorts as the Tramp by the time), here he abandons the sweet-natured hobo to play a villain. The contrast between the diminutive, "bow-legged" Chaplin and the bovine and "bulky" Dressler, adds to the absurdity of their pairing.[8]

Sennett's augmentation of the film length from two reels to six reels provided him with sufficient scope to showcase his ensemble of talented players in numerous venues:

"...many scenes are shot on location, and Sennett intercuts deftly to four different locations. The film’s final reel is a comedic crescendo, building from a brief pie fight to mayhem caused by Tillie firing a pistol indiscriminately, culminating with a farcical chase on a pier featuring the Keystone Cops on land and sea."[9]

The film, which costs roughly $50,000 ($1.2 million in 2015) to make, was based on the Broadway play Tillie's Nightmare,[10] which Dressler had great success in, on Broadway, and on tour in the United States, from 1910 to 1912.[11] Dressler would revive the play with her own touring company.

Milton Berle always claimed that he played the five-year-old paperboy in the film.[12] but the role was actually portrayed by Gordon Griffith.

This is one of only two films (the other is Making a Living, his first film, where he also plays a "dude" non-Tramp character) in which both Chaplin and the Keystone Cops appear.


Following its December 21, 1914 premiere at the Los Angeles Republic Theatre,[13] the film was a tremendous success.[14] As the Mutual Film Corporation, distributors of all Keystone shorts, was not equipped to handle features from them, Tillie became the only Keystone production to be distributed by the newly formed (and short-lived) Alco Film Corporation. It remained in theatrical release for years, being continually re-edited and shortened, and much later having optical soundtracks added featuring music, sound effects and narration.

Home videoEdit

For decades the film was only available in poor quality, truncated prints, but eventually David Shepard of Film Preservation Associates released his restoration on LaserDisc (1997) and DVD (1999) via Image Entertainment. It was coupled with Mabel's Married Life (1914), another Keystone film featuring Normand, Chaplin and Swain. In 2003 a second restoration, a collaboration between UCLA Film and Television Archive and the British Film Institute, used more complete, higher quality materials and saw Tillie returned almost to its original length. This version has been released in the fully restored Chaplin at Keystone 4-DVD box set (2010) by various labels worldwide.[15]


Dressler appeared as Tillie in three more movies, Tillie's Tomato Surprise (1915), Tillie Wakes Up (1917), and The Scrub Lady (1917), aka Tillie the Scrub Lady.

In Tillie Wakes Up, the Tillie character is married and so has a different surname.

The 1928 filmEdit

Another comedy called Tillie's Punctured Romance was released in 1928 starring W. C. Fields as a circus ringmaster. Although often erroneously cited as a remake, the later movie actually bears no resemblance to the 1914 film aside from the shared title and that Chester Conklin and Mack Swain appear in both movies.

In popular cultureEdit

In The Simpsons episode American History X-cellent, one of Mr. Burns' belongings includes a ticket stub for Tillie's Punctured Romance.

See alsoEdit


  1. ^ "Tillie's Punctured Romance". The Progressive Silent Film List. Silent Era. Retrieved 2016-02-09.
  2. ^ Keystone: The Life and Clowns of Mack Sennett by Simon Louvish ISBN 0-571-21276-X
  3. ^ The Chaplin Project film restoration by the British Film Institute, National Film and Television Archive, 2004
  4. ^ "Minta Durfee Filmography". Turner Classic Movies. Archived from the original on October 19, 2015. Retrieved March 13, 2020.
  5. ^ Keystone: The Life and Clowns of Mack Sennett by Simon Louvish ISBN 0-571-21276-X
  6. ^ Pendleton, 2004, UCLA: Dressler "one of the American stage’s most popular actresses in the early 1900s....triumphed as the title character in Tillie’s Nightmare." And: Sennett "the preeminent maker of film comedy" in his day.
  7. ^ Keystone: The Life and Clowns of Mack Sennett by Simon Louvish ISBN 0-571-21276-X
  8. ^ Pendleton, 2004: "Chaplin plays a comically villainous seducer...poles apart from the good-natured Tramp." And: "...much of the humor turns on [Dressler’s] girlish naivete [and] the ungainliness of the actresses bulky physique…"
  9. ^ Pendleton, 2004 UCLA: "...Keystone studios boasted a stable of stars that included Fatty Arbuckle, Mabel Normand, Mack Swain, Edgar Kennedy, Chester Conklin and Charley Chase
  10. ^ Lee 1997, p. 105.
  11. ^ Lee 1997, pp. 77–85.
  12. ^ Neibaur, James L. Early Charlie Chaplin: The Artist as Apprentice at Keystone Studios Scarecrow Press, Inc., 2012, p. 219
  13. ^ BFI 2006.
  14. ^ Reading Eagle 1915, p. 12.
  15. ^ "Charlie Chaplin Collectors' Guide, Part 2: Keystone restorations". Brenton Film. Retrieved 22 June 2017.


  • "33. Tillie's Punctured Romance". BFI. September 2006. Charlie Chaplin. Retrieved 2015-03-17.
  • Lee, Betty (1997). Marie Dressler: the unlikeliest star. University of Kentucky Press. ISBN 0-8131-2036-5.
  • "Empire". Reading Eagle. March 21, 1915. p. 12. Retrieved 2015-03-17.
  • Pendleton, David. 2004. Tillie's Punctured Romance, 1914. UCLA Film and Television Archive: 12th Festival of Preservation, July 22-August 21, 2004. Festival guest handbook.

External linksEdit

  • Tillie's Punctured Romance at IMDb
  • Tillie's Punctured Romance at AllMovie
  • Tillie's Punctured Romance public domain versions at the Internet Archive