You Gave Me the Answer

Summary

"You Gave Me the Answer" is a song by Wings. It was written by Paul McCartney and appeared on the album Venus and Mars.

"You Gave Me the Answer"
Single by Wings
from the album Venus and Mars
A-side"Letting Go"
Released4 October 1975 (US)
18 October 1975 (UK)
Recorded24 January and 4 February 1975
GenreMusic hall, pop
Length2:15
LabelCapitol
Songwriter(s)Paul McCartney and Linda McCartney
Producer(s)Paul McCartney
Wings singles chronology
"Listen to What the Man Said"
(1975)
"You Gave Me the Answer"
(1975)
"Venus and Mars/Rock Show"
(1975)
Venus and Mars track listing
13 tracks
Side one
  1. "Venus and Mars"
  2. "Rock Show"
  3. "Love in Song"
  4. "You Gave Me the Answer"
  5. "Magneto and Titanium Man"
  6. "Letting Go"
Side two
  1. "Venus and Mars (Reprise)"
  2. "Spirits of Ancient Egypt"
  3. "Medicine Jar"
  4. "Call Me Back Again"
  5. "Listen to What the Man Said"
  6. "Treat Her Gently/Lonely Old People"
  7. "Crossroads Theme"

Origin and recording edit

McCartney has occasionally paid tribute to his father, James, who led his own band in his youth, by writing "Music Hall numbers."[1] Other such songs from McCartney's catalogue include "When I'm Sixty-Four" and "Honey Pie".[2] To enhance the realism of this period pastiche, McCartney recorded his lead vocals through a filter that removed much of the lower-end frequencies to help emulate the sound of singing through a megaphone, the signature sound of Rudy Vallee.[3] This was a common recording technique during the 1920s, where singers like Vallee and Al Jolson had to compensate for the poor reception of primitive recording equipment at that time.[original research?]

In concert, McCartney often dedicated this song to Fred Astaire.[1]

Personnel edit

  • Paul McCartney – vocals, bass, piano, string arrangement
  • Jimmy McCulloch – electric guitar
  • Joe English – drums, backing vocals
  • Linda McCartney – backing vocals
  • Tony Dorsey – string arrangement
  • Michael J. Pierce – clarinet
  • Vito Platomone – clarinet
  • Carlos Klejman – violin
  • Russell Joseph Bobrowski – violin
  • Ronald B. Benko – trumpet
  • John K. Branch – viola
  • Harold Joseph Ballam – bassoon
  • Bernard S. Richterman – cello

References edit

  1. ^ a b Flippo, C. (1988). Yesterday: the unauthorized biography of Paul McCartney. Doubleday. p. 20. ISBN 978-0-385-23482-5.
  2. ^ Julien, O. (2008). Sgt. Pepper and the Beatles: It Was Forty Years Ago Today. Ashgate. p. 92. ISBN 978-0-7546-6708-7.
  3. ^ Kelly, Kate (20 September 2023). "How the Microphone Changed Music: No Way To Amplify Sound". americacomesalive.com. Retrieved 9 March 2024. Singing bandleader Rudy Vallee ... used a megaphone to help amplify his voice over the sound of his band.